Was Jamie Dukes out of line on Ryan Mallett?

[skinsfaninok]

Comp % is good but it's all about winning my man, that's the bottom line, Rodgers and Brees are amazing no doubt but if they are elite then rivers and Eli could be also, remember Eli has won a SB

[skinsfaninok]

Ok it's good there and I was basically talking about garrard, he's a decent player nothing more

[skinsfaninok]

And point blank David garrard is avg at best nothing much better than Campbell which u thought was a crazy statement

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

And point blank David garrard is avg at best nothing much better than Campbell which u thought was a crazy statement

I said taking Campbell over Garrard would get you fired.

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

Ok it's good there and I was basically talking about garrard, he's a decent player nothing more

Never said Garrard was special. I said 64% was good, you said it was decent, then I listed all the top QBs whose % was right at or even lower than 64%, then you went all Charlie Sheen on me and started talking about "winning"

[skinsfaninok]

Lol ok but u said winning isnt everything so if rivers and romo put up The same numbers and win many many games I'd say they are elite them too. Again that's a strong word. I give u the comp % argument but I'll take The elite argument, be reasonable. I'm out buddy it was a good discussion

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

Lol ok but u said winning isnt everything so if rivers and romo put up The same numbers and win many many games I'd say they are elite them too. Again that's a strong word. I give u the comp % argument but I'll take The elite argument, be reasonable. I'm out buddy it was a good discussion

Where did I say winning isnt everything? It's the only thing but that was irrevelant to our conversation. Not giving you the elite argument.


4,000 yard plus his first two seasons, Professionally, Rodgers is the NFL's all-time career leader in passer rating during both the regular season (98.4), and in the post-season (112.6) ? among passers with at least 1,500 and 150 pass attempts respectively. He also owns the league's lowest career pass interception percentage for quarterbacks during the regular season (1.99%)

Yeah he is no where near elite

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

Comp % is good but it's all about winning my man, that's the bottom line, Rodgers and Brees are amazing no doubt but if they are elite then rivers and Eli could be also, remember Eli has won a SB

Winning has nothing to do with what we were talking about. Trent Dilfer won a SB, as did Brad Johnson. Winning a SB doesn't make you elite.

[skinsfaninok]

So is Tony romo elite? He puts up the same numbers as Rodgers basically. Is rivers elite? I mean 6 QBs aren't elite my man come on

[skinsfaninok]

And how would that get me fired? Garrard and JC are equal my Man, both are avg QBs. No arguing that

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

And how would that get me fired? Garrard and JC are equal my Man, both are avg QBs. No arguing that

Yes there is, I'll take Garrard over JC any day.

[skinsfaninok]

Alright we will end it at that lol good stuff though it's funny how ryan Mallett turned into every QB in the league. Good stuff my man and Rodgers is damn close I'll give u that. HTTR

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

So is Tony romo elite? He puts up the same numbers as Rodgers basically. Is rivers elite? I mean 6 QBs aren't elite my man come on

Romo no turns the ball over too much
Rivers getting there

Brees
Brady
Manning
Rodgers
4 elite QBs IDK where you got 6