Eli Manning vs Jason Campbell

[SC Skins Fan]

Originally Posted by saden1

Cut the f'ing bulsh*t people, Eli is much better than JC. Period!

They are both average players, though Manning was slightly above average in 2008.

Doing it by Football Outsiders DVOA over the past three seasons:

Manning:

2006 - Manning (3.9%), Campbell (-0.7%)
2007 - Manning (-13.1%), Campbell (-12.3%)
2008 - Manning (19.7%), Campbell (8.3%)

Saying Campbell compares favorably to Eli Manning is not saying Campbell is a great player, it is saying Manning is far from a great player.