Carlos Rogers Playing Well

[Meks]

he didn't wanna play here plain n simple, I like Josh Wilson, I hope he pans out to be a great replacement in the long run... id take Los over d.hall prolly as well, prolly is huge tho I dunno ... not sure on that one

[Alvin Walton]

Pfffftttt....whatever......he's a 49er, he can bite me.
Thank for being average while you were here Mr. Granite Hands.

[zeesson]

Originally Posted by Meks

he didn't wanna play here plain n simple, I like Josh Wilson, I hope he pans out to be a great replacement in the long run... id take Los over d.hall prolly as well, prolly is huge tho I dunno ... not sure on that one

Whoa, Whoa, Whoa... what's this talk about rather having Rogers than D.Hall? This is mind blowing. Sure D.Hall takes risks sometimes, and get's caught out of position as a result, but when the easy ones, and a great many of the difficult ones, bounce his way, he is coming down with pigskin-in-hand. I can't count how many times Rogers had the opportunity to change the game, or seal the win for us, and all he had to do was catch a lofty Charmin Ultra Soft- like ball, and simply blew it. I've literally seen this guy drop interceptions that my grandmother could catch. Carlos Rogers was the Graham Gano of our secondary. Sure, he could make a 45+ yarder, but with the game on the line, and only a 25 yarder to make, he blows it.

Don't get me wrong. There are plenty of corners that I would rather have than D.Hall, but Carlos Rogers isn't even in the discussion.