Skinsfaninok's Available NFL QBs Poll

[SmootSmack]

I'm torn between Smith and Young.

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

I'm torn between Smith and Young.

I watched VY against dallas last year and he shredded them, I'm with Young for now.

I knew Kolb would run away with it also but I didn't pick him because there is NO chance Phi will trade us 2 QB's in back to back summers

[Giantone]

Considering the coaching staff I would go with Palmer....I think he pairs up well with Shanahan(both of them).

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by Giantone

Considering the coaching staff I would go with Palmer....I think he pairs up well with Shanahan(both of them).

Palmer is a statue, MS likes guys who can move around

[gafinfan]

None of the above ..... and Kolb for sure, are you kidding me. Ask yourself this question "Has a Reed developed QB from Philly been successful anywhere else?" Please name one. No, I rest my case!

Keven Kolb ....... Buyer beware!

Oh and BTW I don't want him in Miami either, we've already road tested a Reed castoff, not no but hell no!

[Dirtbag59]

Originally Posted by gafinfan

None of the above ..... and Kolb for sure, are you kidding me. Ask yourself this question "Has a Reed developed QB from Philly been successful anywhere else?" Please name one. No, I rest my case!

Keven Kolb ....... Buyer beware!

Oh and BTW I don't want him in Miami either, we've already road tested a Reed castoff, not no but hell no!

Brett Favre?

[SmootSmack]

Originally Posted by Dirtbag59

Brett Favre?

When did Favre play in Philly?

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by Dirtbag59

Brett Favre?

U mean ATLANTA?

[Dirtbag59]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

U mean ATLANTA?

Reid was the QB coach in Green Bay where his experience there landed him the head gig in Philly. Either way I thought it would be fun to cherry pick an answer and mess with Quake.

[Dirtbag59]

Anyway as I said before the Vince Young has stirred up mixed feelings in me.

Pro Vince: He's a former top 5 pick with all the talent in the world, arm, mobility, height. He was clutch in college and seems to find ways to win even if they aren't pretty. He also opens up the running game like Vick did in Atlanta where teams had to respect him on play fakes. In fact part of the reason CJ28 was so succesful in Tenneesee was due to the fact that teams had to respect Young and protect the backside leaving cut back lanes for Johnson.

He stands up for his teammates and in spite of his off field problems is still a good person. Kyle also knows a good bit about him after having been his teammate at Texas for a year and most likely following him closely after graduation. Young is also younger then Beck so with all things being equal the Skins would get 3 extra years out of Young.

Anti Vince: Vince Young was rarely counted to take over games with his arm. Many of his games have him throwing for under 200 yards. His win-loss record is great but atrocious against playoff teams, not to mention the fact that Kerry Collins went 12-2 in 2008, so chances are the team won in spite of who was under Center.

Also part of the off field problems Young had stemmed from problems with the coaching staff after being benched. Young certainly didn't throw teammates under the bus a la T.O but still created a media distraction. If you bring him on you have to be sure of his ability to beat out Beck and Grossman who are in years 2 and 3 of the Shanahan system. Young also has accuracy problems at times, a quality that cost McNabb dearly in 2010, though it should be noted that Young isn't nearly as bad as McNabb when it comes to accuracy.

If the Redskins were to struggle with Beck and Grossman few would bat an eye at a QB change and Shanahan would have more freedom to play the hot hand. However if the Skins bring in Young and he plays bad enough to get benched then the media will have a field day.


In the end I will trust the coaching staff.