Rank The Best Modern Day Pitchers

[Monkeydad]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

I don't know if there will ever be a Maddux again. Ever. If it were not for Greg Maddux, I probably would not like baseball.

1. Greg Maddux - He's the face of the modern era. At least, the steroid-free modern era.

2. Pedro Martinez - My greatest wish for Zack Greinke is that his career looks something like Pedro's when it's all said and done. In his prime, no one has ever been better.

3. Randy Johnson - I don't think people realize just how good Randy Johnson has been. Curt Schilling was having some of his best years, and he was unquestionably his team's No. 2 starter.

4. Bert Blyleven - I know for sure that people don't realize how good he was. I'm counting him as part of the modern era since he's still HOF eligible.

5. Johan Santana - Over the last five years, no one in the game has been better.

6. Roy Halladay - Should have gotten the AL Cy Young last year over Cliff Lee. While Lee was more valuable by the pitch, Roy's amazing durability, inning eating ability, and strikeout consistency would have given him my vote. Five years from now, he's still going to be an annual Cy Young threat.

7. Tom Glavine - His remarkable durability often gets lost in reasons why the Braves were so good for so long, and even John Smoltz missed much of this decade and found himself in relief. Glavine has his perception a little bit by hanging on too long, but he's an absolute lock for the HOF, which Smoltz is not.

8. Roger Clemens - The other face of the era, for different reasons, Clemens was no better than the seventh or eight best pitcher, but was dominating in his prime, and did it for a long time.

9. Bret Saberhagen - In the late eighties, he was Pedro before there was a Pedro.

10. Mike Mussina - Numbers say: better than Schilling.

Great call with Saberhagen, he's usually forgotten.

I'd move Pedro way down and Clemens up o #1 or #2, but your list looks decent. Halladay and Santana will be on the list, but not yet. Replace him with maybe Kevin Appier or Chuck Finley.
Blyleven was great, but all but about his last 2 seasons were outside the past 20 years.

Mine:

1. GREG MADDUX
2. ROGER CLEMENS
3. RANDY JOHNSON
4. TOM GLAVINE
5. DAVID CONE
6. JOHN SMOLTZ
7. MIKE MUSSINA
8. PEDRO MARTINEZ
9. BRET SABERHAGEN
10. CHUCK FINLEY