A Grimm Fairy Tale

[FRPLG]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

Why not? He won a SB, the next year was NFL MVP and NFL offensive player of the year and let us to another SB and was in charge of team that set an all time NFL scoring record that has been broken twice since then. Not great stats but pretty good accomplishments.

Pretty good accomplsihments do not a HOFer make. There are lots of people with good acomplishments that aren't in the HOF. The HOF is for the best, the game changers, record setters and memorable players. Joey T isn't even close to a HOFer. He was a good QB like Kerry Collins or Matt Hasslebeck. None of them is a HOFer. Guys like Montana, Young, Manning, Brady are HOFers.