SF Postgame

[skinsfan0201]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

Having Gibson takes the pressure of Alex, the turf didn't help Alex and being nervous facing the 49ers swarming D didn't help. I think he'll bounce back, but yes we need a future QB.

Wow, the doubters are back, even with a win and an injury to Alex... i’d say fair weather, but it’s already defined by your comment.

Sad

[SFREDSKIN]

Originally Posted by skinsfan0201

Wow, the doubters are back, even with a win and an injury to Alex... i’d say fair weather, but it’s already defined by your comment.

Sad

Just being realistic and who are you? Alex's fluffer?

[skinsfan0201]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

Just being realistic and who are you? Alex's fluffer?

Just an educator, and a coach for many years understanding what Alex has done.

[skinsfan0201]

Originally Posted by skinsfan0201

Just an educator, and a coach for many years understanding what Alex has done.

And can still do ....

[SFREDSKIN]

Originally Posted by skinsfan0201

Just an educator, and a coach for many years understanding what Alex has done.

I know what Alex has done which is amazing and at the same I'm time being realistic. Don't tell me he isn't playing scared sometimes? Do you blame him? Hell no!! If you or I or anyone else suffered that type of injury he suffered, there is no way we would have recovered like he did.

He is 36 years old and has suffered a devastating injury which he has recovered from, the fact that he is on the field playing is amazing, his better days are behind him, his scrambling ability is gone. Having Gibson on the field helps him, don't tell me it doesn't. that turf didn't help his reconstructed leg today and I'm sure he'll bounce back, but he is not the future answer.

[skinsfan0201]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

I know what Alex has done which is amazing and at the same I'm time being realistic. Don't tell me he isn't playing scared sometimes? Do you blame him? Hell no!! If you or I or anyone else suffered that type of injury he suffered, there is no way we would have recovered like he did.

He is 36 years old and has suffered a devastating injury which he has recovered from, the fact that he is on the field playing is amazing, his better days are behind him. Having Gibson on the field helps him, don't tell me it doesn't. that turf didn't help his reconstructed leg today and I'm sure he'll bounce back, but his is not the future answer.

We have not a clue what kind of “muscle “ injury he has. The fact that the team is taking precautions his first month and a half starting again is a good thing. I don’t think he would be out there doing what he has done unless he is feeling well. If today was any indication, we should feel better knowing that our team understands the importance of him starting the rest of the season etc. They know his capabilities and limitations better than any of us do. For us to make any assumptions is ludicrous. Alex Smith has done something no one else in any sport has ever done, give the man a shot.

[SFREDSKIN]

Originally Posted by skinsfan0201

We have not a clue what kind of “muscle “ injury he has. The fact that the team is taking precautions his first month and a half starting again is a good thing. I don’t think he would be out there doing what he has done unless he is feeling well. If today was any indication, we should feel better knowing that our team understands the importance of him starting the rest of the season etc. They know his capabilities and limitations better than any of us do. For us to make any assumptions is ludicrous. Alex Smith has done something no one else in any sport has ever done, give the man a shot.

I am, if you would have read my previous comment carefully I said he would bounce back, I give him the benefit of the doubt as he is our best option. Next year we need to upgrade the position. He will be 37 years old and will always be limited due to his injury, at least his scrambling ability which was one of his main strengths. We just need to get younger at QB.

[skinsfan0201]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

I am, if you would have read my previous comment carefully I said he would bounce back, I give him the benefit of the doubt as he is our best option. Next year we need to upgrade the position. He will be 37 years old and will always be limited due to his injury, at least his scrambling ability which was one of his main strengths. We just need to get younger at QB.

Well, it seemed like you gave him some benefit, but knowing that this is his first month and a half back as well as the fact that he has many strengths besides just being a “good” scrambler. Being able to read and understand what he is seeing on the field, processing his reads/progressions, mentoring the other young offensive players, teaching them and understanding situational football is not something we will find next season in the NFL draft.

[skinsfan69]

Originally Posted by skinsfan0201

We have not a clue what kind of “muscle “ injury he has. The fact that the team is taking precautions his first month and a half starting again is a good thing. I don’t think he would be out there doing what he has done unless he is feeling well. If today was any indication, we should feel better knowing that our team understands the importance of him starting the rest of the season etc. They know his capabilities and limitations better than any of us do. For us to make any assumptions is ludicrous. Alex Smith has done something no one else in any sport has ever done, give the man a shot.

He does not pass the eye test. He is slow and can't push the ball downfield. We have to draft someone like Josh Allen. If we can do that we are on our way to competing for a SB.

[skinsfan0201]

Originally Posted by skinsfan69

He does not pass the eye test. He is slow and can't push the ball downfield. We have to draft someone like Josh Allen. If we can do that we are on our way to competing for a SB.

Again, Franchise quarterbacks don’t grow on trees. Eye test, is completely subjective and obviously for you it’s stat filled. Josh Allen is a great player, but there is unlikely to be that caliber of a quarterback in the draft.

[punch it in]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

Just being realistic and who are you? Alex's fluffer?

Lolol. Seriously. Anyone who thinks Smiths best days are ahead of him is just oblivious. Great story. It is over after this year.

[WCommandersfan99]

Very happy about the W. However the qb play was terrible. Smith was bad today and I was surprised. Look I know SF has a good defense, but he was inaccurate on a lot of balls. Hopefully he'll rebound soon. Not ready to give up on him yet for sure.

Love, love this defense. The dline is awesome even without Matty I. Chase Young is a monster along with Sweat. Allen, Payne, and Settle are great. Incredible how many big plays they have made during this 4 game streak. The dline literally won us the game today despite SF having almost twice as many yards. Just crazy.

Bigtime shoutout to Kamren Curl. Making the Sooner state looking good. Boy can play. He is everywhere and loves contact. We found a gem here guys.

HTWFT!