Giants Pre Game dumpster fire thread

[MTK]

Smith is a great comeback story no doubt but it's clear he should have been pulled from that game.

Sloppy field, Allen was cleared, Rams pass rush was ferocious, I really don't get what Ron was thinking there at all.

I don't even think he should be active, bring up Montez from the PS and make him the backup.

I also think it's ridiculous Dwayne wasn't made the backup. He would have given us a fighting chance.

[Redskins247]

Originally Posted by MTK

Smith is a great comeback story no doubt but it's clear he should have been pulled from that game.

Sloppy field, Allen was cleared, Rams pass rush was ferocious, I really don't get what Ron was thinking there at all.

I don't even think he should be active, bring up Montez from the PS and make him the backup.

I also think it's ridiculous Dwayne wasn't made the backup. He would have given us a fighting chance.

This. This is what has me really questioning what the hell Ron is doing.

[Chief X_Phackter]

Let's stop babying Alex Smith already. He's cleared to play, and he's the most experienced QB on the roster. Of course he's the backup at this point.

[KI Skins Fan]

Originally Posted by Chief X_Phackter

Let's stop babying Alex Smith already. He's cleared to play, and he's the most experienced QB on the roster. Of course he's the backup at this point.

I have no idea why Alex Smith is on an NFL team. He should not be playing NFL football after his injury. He isn't mobile enough to protect himself so he should retire. Hopefully, his retirement won't come about due to his being seriously injured again.

[punch it in]

Originally Posted by KI Skins Fan

I have no idea why Alex Smith is on an NFL team. He should not be playing NFL football after his injury. He isn't mobile enough to protect himself so he should retire. Hopefully, his retirement won't come about due to his being seriously injured again.

Well wait a minute. How many quarterbacks are not mobile? From everything I hear Smiths leg is as good as any other leg or at least his old leg lol. He has been out for quite some time. I think he just needs to get back up to speed. I realize he is 38 but if given the reps im sure he could be an extremely serviceable backup and probably start for a couple years or so.

[Chico23231]

Originally Posted by MTK

Smith is a great comeback story no doubt but it's clear he should have been pulled from that game.

Sloppy field, Allen was cleared, Rams pass rush was ferocious, I really don't get what Ron was thinking there at all.

I don't even think he should be active, bring up Montez from the PS and make him the backup.

I also think it's ridiculous Dwayne wasn't made the backup. He would have given us a fighting chance.

Exactly. So again we are blowing the QB position on how to handle “the move on” situation. Instead of trying to move him for maximum value, we have leaked stories to destroy his character and we will get nothing.

Bruce is gone, yet we are doing the samething organization-wise.

So fucking stupid

[irish]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

Exactly. So again we are blowing the QB position on how to handle “the move on” situation. Instead of trying to move him for maximum value, we have leaked stories to destroy his character and we will get nothing.

Bruce is gone, yet we are doing the samething organization-wise.

So fucking stupid

As my post above says I also think DH should be the backup. The only reason I can think that he wont be is because RR sees him as a potential locker room cancer that if allowed to return to the locker room will make a bad situation even worse.