Alex Smith’s Amazing Comeback(?)

[EdmundDorf]

Originally Posted by MTK

If he’s on PUP pretty sure that means he failed the physical

Not necessarily, the local reporters, Keim and Findley, mentioned that if the player does not start camp on the PUP list then he cannot then be moved onto it at a later date, so starting him on the PUP list is just keeping their options open in case he can't quite make it yet during training camp

[MTK]

Originally Posted by EdmundDorf

Not necessarily, the local reporters, Keim and Findley, mentioned that if the player does not start camp on the PUP list then he cannot then be moved onto it at a later date, so starting him on the PUP list is just keeping their options open in case he can't quite make it yet during training camp

A player can't go on PUP if they pass the physical, so they must have failed him on his.

[SolidSnake84]

Per Ron Rivera both Alex Smith and Rueben Foster failed their physicals.