Cowpukes postgame finger pointing thread

[SFREDSKIN]

I saw Jackson tugged by the jersey no call, Whitner penalty shouldn't have. Personal foul called as his momentum had him moving and could not stop, many other bullshit non calls by their DB's holding in the endzone.

[FrenchSkin]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

I saw Jackson tugged by the jersey no call, Whitner penalty shouldn't have. Personal foul called as his momentum had him moving and could not stop, many other bullshit non calls by their DB's holding in the endzone.

To me it clearly was a penalty, QB sliding down, Whitner late and leading with his helmet... Overall, considering how bad refereeing is this season, I won't complain about the refs on this game, some missed calls but nothing game changing IMO. We made enough mistakes on our side to lose this one.

I may sound monomaniac, but I really don't see what Whitner is bringing to the table... Missed tackles, slow, gets beaten on coverage, doesn't ever break out from his blocks... I know you may say he's not the one costing us the game but I really don't see why you would play him over Ihenacho. I'm fine with Duke and Blackmon.

[SFREDSKIN]

Originally Posted by FrenchSkin

To me it clearly was a penalty, QB sliding down, Whitner late and leading with his helmet... Overall, considering how bad refereeing is this season, I won't complain about the refs on this game, some missed calls but nothing game changing IMO. We made enough mistakes on our side to lose this one.

I may sound monomaniac, but I really don't see what Whitner is bringing to the table... Missed tackles, slow, gets beaten on coverage, doesn't ever break out from his blocks... I know you may say he's not the one costing us the game but I really don't see why you would play him over Ihenacho. I'm fine with Duke and Blackmon.

He's the best stopgap available, you got someone in mind that would be better? Have to wait till next years draft to DL, DE/OLB, S, ILB. This team's defense is a player or 2 away from being excellent.

[FrenchSkin]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

He's the best stopgap available, you got someone in mind that would be better? Have to wait till next years draft to DL, DE/OLB, S, ILB. This team's defense is a player or 2 away from being excellent.

Agreed on that bolded part 100% !

Still not sold on Whitner, did he make a play since we signed him? I have a hard time seeing him as our best stopgap available since he misses too many tackles for my taste

[SFREDSKIN]

Originally Posted by FrenchSkin

Agreed on that bolded part 100% !

Still not sold on Whitner, did he make a play since we signed him? I have a hard time seeing him as our best stopgap available since he misses too many tackles for my taste

Like I said, who else is available? Whitner is slow but at least he can tackle (maybe so-so lately). That penalty if you see it in realtime, he couldn't stop and wasn't late. The hit on Reed in the endzone should have been a 15 yard penalty.

[SFREDSKIN]

Reed is a man!!

Jordan Reed plays through shoulder injury sustained early in loss, excels against Cowboys

[punch it in]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

He's the best stopgap available, you got someone in mind that would be better? Have to wait till next years draft to DL, DE/OLB, S, ILB. This team's defense is a player or 2 away from being excellent.

They are a player or three away from being good enough that we will win because our offense rocks.....