QB Prospects Thread

[sdskinsfan2001]

I don't know why, but for some reason I think we somehow end up w/ J.J. McCarthy. Not based on any evidence, news, facts, etc., just a random feeling.

He's actually starting to grow on me.

I wouldn't be mad at it.

[CRedskinsRule]

Originally Posted by sdskinsfan2001

I don't know why, but for some reason I think we somehow end up w/ J.J. McCarthy. Not based on any evidence, news, facts, etc., just a random feeling.



He's actually starting to grow on me.



I wouldn't be mad at it.

I really wouldn't be shocked if that happened, but I wonder if we have him or any other than Maye and JD scheduled for pro days.

Sent from my SM-G781U using Tapatalk

[Chief X_Phackter]

I don't care who they pick. If they like JJ - fine, but take him at #2. If you think he's the franchise guy over Maye or Daniels - no reason to play games and trade back thinking you could get him elsewhere in the top 10 or wherever they would end up.

I think it will be Maye or Daniels at #2 though. I just don't know which one they want, and that's a good thing.

[sdskinsfan2001]

Originally Posted by Chief X_Phackter

I don't care who they pick. If they like JJ - fine, but take him at #2. If you think he's the franchise guy over Maye or Daniels - no reason to play games and trade back thinking you could get him elsewhere in the top 10 or wherever they would end up.

I think it will be Maye or Daniels at #2 though. I just don't know which one they want, and that's a good thing.

Daniels > McCarthy > Maye is my pecking order right now. But yeah, I'll take any of them, and trust the new FO/staff is correct.

Gotta start out thinking positively. Don't want let the past dictate the future.

[punch it in]

McCarthy is the only other guy that even remotely comes to mind to be our pick at quarterback but it is really remote. Like the darkest recesses of the universe remote.
He has a weakish arm and was propped up by a really great team around him, staff too. Hard pass for me, but there is always the Tom Brady thing that happens so .

[sdskinsfan2001]

Originally Posted by punch it in

McCarthy is the only other guy that even remotely comes to mind to be our pick at quarterback but it is really remote. Like the darkest recesses of the universe remote.
He has a weakish arm and was propped up by a really great team around him, staff too. Hard pass for me, but there is always the Tom Brady thing that happens so .

I didn't watch him play much. But he has great accuracy and ball placement. He seems to know exactly where the ball needs to be placed in solid coverage. That will translate to the NFL. No. 2 might be a little high based on pure physical attributes, but if we did pick him there, I'd rock with it.

Basically every pick is a toss-up gamble anyways.

I'm jacked up for 4/25/2024 though. I liked our FA. If we can come out of our 1st 3 picks with a QB/OT/Misc., I'm good to go.

[Chico23231]

Originally Posted by punch it in

McCarthy is the only other guy that even remotely comes to mind to be our pick at quarterback but it is really remote. Like the darkest recesses of the universe remote.
He has a weakish arm and was propped up by a really great team around him, staff too. Hard pass for me, but there is always the Tom Brady thing that happens so .

Agree.

I think there is a bit of a honeymoon effect with JD which will fade. Peters will pick Maye but will feel out the Bears for Williams at 1 first.

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by sdskinsfan2001

I didn't watch him play much. But he has great accuracy and ball placement. He seems to know exactly where the ball needs to be placed in solid coverage. That will translate to the NFL. No. 2 might be a little high based on pure physical attributes, but if we did pick him there, I'd rock with it.

Basically every pick is a toss-up gamble anyways.

I'm jacked up for 4/25/2024 though. I liked our FA. If we can come out of our 1st 3 picks with a QB/OT/Misc., I'm good to go.

They literally went halves without throwing the ball at times, for me its Daniels and Maye, I would be shocked if the pick was anyone else at #2.

[WCommandersfan99]

Originally Posted by EARTHQUAKE2689

They literally went halves without throwing the ball at times, for me its Daniels and Maye, I would be shocked if the pick was anyone else at #2.

Yes agree. Maye has all the tools. Love the fact that he's tall, great arm and can run. Nearly impossible to find a qb with that combination. Like Daniels also, but size and arm strength worry me. Great, quick release though and lethal runner.

[skinsfaninok]

This QB draft class better end up being top 5 of all time with the hype all of these dudes are getting. It shows you how BAD the NFL is right now with QB play

[mredskins]

Exactly what was the point of this thread that isn't already discussed in multiply threads?

[mredskins]

Originally Posted by Chief X_Phackter

I don't care who they pick. If they like JJ - fine, but take him at #2. If you think he's the franchise guy over Maye or Daniels - no reason to play games and trade back thinking you could get him elsewhere in the top 10 or wherever they would end up.

I think it will be Maye or Daniels at #2 though. I just don't know which one they want, and that's a good thing.

what i love just LOVE to see is when we pick whomever it is I want see the faces of the new england draft war room; i love to see if they are disappointed with whom we picked or excited we missed on their guy

[punch it in]

Originally Posted by WCommandersfan99

Yes agree. Maye has all the tools. Love the fact that he's tall, great arm and can run. Nearly impossible to find a qb with that combination. Like Daniels also, but size and arm strength worry me. Great, quick release though and lethal runner.

Daniels has great deep ball accuracy but apparently struggles with zip on the ball on shorter throws. Not sure it is arm strength as much as confidence when he has to make a decision with a tight window.

[punch it in]

Originally Posted by mredskins

Exactly what was the point of this thread that isn't already discussed in multiply threads?

This thread is solely about the number two pick, or who our future quarterback will be.

[mredskins]

Originally Posted by punch it in

This thread is solely about the number two pick, or who our future quarterback will be.

oh ok i must have missed the subtitle