Switch to 3-4 Defense a Failure

[jdc65]

In my opinion, the 3-4 is fine if you have either a superior DE or NT to go along with a very strong linebacking corps. Every team rushes 4 men as a basic package, and the goal is to apply consistant pressure with a 4 man rush. It makes the blitz so much more effective.

The problem is logistical. It is increasingly difficult to find a 6-4, 300 lb 3-4 DE who can take on double teams and still get penetration. Teams like SF, Hou, Ari, and SD have those superior players. Other teams like Pit and GB have 330 lb 3-4 NT's who can consistantly take on double teams and push the pocket. Those teams can get constant pressure with a 4 man rush, and their blitzes work.

The Redskins don't have those guys in the front 3, all can be handled with a single blocker. When the Skins rush their 4th guy, it is an easy pickup for the O-line. They have to rush 5 guys to apply any pressure, and only then will the blitz be effective with 6-7 rushers whereas other strong defenses get it with 5.

It is much easier to find a 6-1, 300 pounder who can play 4-3 DT and get penetration beating a single blocker than a 6-2, 330 lb 3-4 NT who can consistantly occupy 2 blockers. And it is easier to get a 6-3, 260 lb 4-3 DE who can speed rush past 1 blocker than a 6-5, 300 lb 3-4 DE who can consistantly take doubles.

4-3 teams are just easier to build, and compounding the problem is most college teams want lighter, speedier defenders to attack the wide open college game. Alabama is a rare exception that runs a base 3-4, but Saban can have his choice of any kid in the country to fit his scheme. Most college teams want their kids on the track getting quicker and faster as opposed to the dining room getting bigger.

It is still about getting consistant pressure with a 4 man rush, and if you can find those guys, the 3-4 works fine. The Skins don't have them, and they need to find them. Otherwise a 4 man front with Kerrigan, Orakpo, Cofield, and Bowen/Jenkins would appear to be their best course going forward. All are 4-3 players ideally as better penetrators rather than occupiers. My opinion only.