Where does D. Hall rate as a CB for the Redskins all time?

[12thMan]

Originally Posted by Lotus

DHall is the new Jason Campbell. JC was so middle-of-the-road that lovers found plenty to love, haters found plenty to hate, and therefore endless arguments resulted. For different reasons, of course, DHall polarizes the fan base in just the same way.

In some sense I even take exception to that comparison for many reasons. But namely I can't remember one game where Jason Campbell put the team on his back and single-handedly drove the team to victory or he was the deciding factor in a victorious outcome. I think it's safe to say, D.Hall has produced a few of those games in his short time as a Redskin.

But I'm done with this thread and this argument. I'm starting to sound like D.Hall is the second coming of Christ and that's not the position I'm taking at all.

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by 12thMan

But I'm done with this thread and this argument. I'm starting to sound like D.Hall is the second coming of Christ and that's not the position I'm taking at all.

12th, I have great respect for you for doing this. Even though we disagree, you've proven to be the "bigger" man.

I'll be back in this thread before long, ttyl.

[Ruhskins]

Originally Posted by 12thMan

In some sense I even take exception to that comparison for many reasons. But namely I can't remember one game where Jason Campbell put the team on his back and single-handedly drove the team to victory or he was the deciding factor in a victorious outcome. I think it's safe to say, D.Hall has produced a few of those games in his short time as a Redskin.

But I'm done with this thread and this argument. I'm starting to sound like D.Hall is the second coming of Christ and that's not the position I'm taking at all.

I think Lotus was talking about just being a polarizing player. The loudest people in this argument are the ones that think that Hall is the best CB of all time AND those who think Hall is destroying the Redskins worst than Vinny. But yeah, this thread and this argument is getting a bit tiring. I'm ready for the season to start and root for all the players in the Redskins roster.