SI's Top 10 QB's Under age 25

[steveo395]

That list is pretty retarded. Jay Cutler hasn't taken a snap yet, Aaron Rodgers has barely played, Vince Young has been pretty crappy so far. Isn't this supposed to be a list of the top QBs 25 and under? This shouldn't be based on potential. I'm not really sure what they based this on. And yea, Alex Smith should be a lot higher than 10.


I'm sure 0421Kidwell could make a good ranking for you...but he might have to start a new thread for it.

[Rexi]

Originally Posted by steveo395

That list is pretty retarded. Jay Cutler hasn't taken a snap yet, Aaron Rodgers has barely played, Vince Young has been pretty crappy so far. Isn't this supposed to be a list of the top QBs 25 and under? This shouldn't be based on potential. I'm not really sure what they based this on. And yea, Alex Smith should be a lot higher than 10.


I'm sure 0421Kidwell could make a good ranking for you...but he might have to start a new thread for it.

LOL yeah I agree. I think Alex is #10 because some people still can't get their thick skulls around the 1-11 statistic.