Understanding Hard-Hitting Rules

[44ever]

I think a good idea would be to keep everything the way it is except add a upstairs review to bad calls. Get so many a game just like instant replay. Sorta instant replay on the refs.

[skinsfan69]

The crappy calls aren't just with the wr's. The refs are throwing personal fouls if a defender is falling into a Qb's knee. As if a defender can stop his momentum while being pushed by an olinemen. I guess it's the Carson Palmer Tom Brady rule. It's like if a popular QB gets hurt the NFL has to make up a rule to try and justify it.

[mlmpetert]

Can anyone explain the 15 yarder on Moss last night?

[SouperMeister]

Originally Posted by mlmpetert

Can anyone explain the 15 yarder on Moss last night?

That was a terrible call against the Cowboys. A shoulder pad to the sternum should always be considered a clean play. What's a DB to do? Let the receiver catch the ball, then gently lay the receiver on the ground? As long as the contact isn't made on the receiver's head or delivered by the defender's helmet, the hit should be legal.

[skinsfan69]

Originally Posted by mlmpetert

Can anyone explain the 15 yarder on Moss last night?

Maybe the worst call of the year. The refs were just god awful.

[mlmpetert]

Honestly i think it may been a good call on a rule that appears nothing short of terrible .....

I sent a email to the NFL about the rule today for clarification. Although ive emailed the NFL several times and PFT once before about specifics no avail so im not really expecting anything.....

[MTK]

Penalize now, ask questions later.