2022 Commanders off season thread part 1

[WCommandersfan99]

Starting to really wonder what the strategy is. We don't have a ton of great backs and McKissic made our offense much better. So far other than getting Wentz, we no longer have Collins, Scherff, Settle, and now McKissic. People can spin it any way they want but are all notables losses.

[Chief X_Phackter]

Originally Posted by The Skinsinator

Starting to really wonder what the strategy is. We don't have a ton of great backs and McKissic made our offense much better. So far other than getting Wentz, we no longer have Collins, Scherff, Settle, and now McKissic. People can spin it any way they want but are all notables losses.

Scherff and Settle were known losses. Collins was gone if he didn't restructure. JDM played well enough to sign for more elsewhere. I don't see any of these losses as a surprise, or detrimental to the team's success. We have a significant upgrade at the most important position, and it's literally day two of free agency.

[WCommandersfan99]

Originally Posted by Chief X_Phackter

Scherff and Settle were known losses. Collins was gone if he didn't restructure. JDM played well enough to sign for more elsewhere. I don't see any of these losses as a surprise, or detrimental to the team's success. We have a significant upgrade at the most important position, and it's literally day two of free agency.

They are all detrimental to the team's success in some form by losing them. Scherff is an All Pro guard and our oline clearly was worse when he was gone. Collins provided good run support although not quite as upset about him being gone. Settle I figured would be leaving but guy still had talent just to many guys on the dline already. Offense was much better with McKissic. Good runner/receiver who seemed to open things up. Will see the final team as I know we're getting started, but all these guys did bring some value to us.

[Chief X_Phackter]

I like JDM a lot, and he produced well here - had some big plays/games. That said, his production is replaceable. He was TH's security blanket on passing downs since he can't really get the ball down the field. With Carson, that is not an issue and I see the offense morphing to his strengths which makes bringing back JDM less important, especially at a premium. Gibson can catch the ball out of the backfield, as can Patterson, and we will probably see less of that anyway.

[WCommandersfan99]

Originally Posted by Chief X_Phackter

I like JDM a lot, and he produced well here - had some big plays/games. That said, his production is replaceable. He was TH's security blanket on passing downs since he can't really get the ball down the field. With Carson, that is not an issue and I see the offense morphing to his strengths which makes bringing back JDM less important, especially at a premium. Gibson can catch the ball out of the backfield, as can Patterson, and we will probably see less of that anyway.

They must think highly of Patterson and his long term prospects here. Hope they are right for sure.

[Chief X_Phackter]

I didn't say they didn't bring value, just that their signing elsewhere isn't a detriment to this team. They can be replaced. If you asked me 10 days ago if I'd rather have a legit starting QB, or retain Settle, Scherff, Collins, and Mckissic - it's a no brainer. Give me the QB.

We're about 24 hours into free agency. There is plenty that can and will be done before it's over.

[WCommandersfan99]

Originally Posted by Chief X_Phackter

I didn't say they didn't bring value, just that their signing elsewhere isn't a detriment to this team. They can be replaced. If you asked me 10 days ago if I'd rather have a legit starting QB, or retain Settle, Scherff, Collins, and Mckissic - it's a no brainer. Give me the QB.

We're about 24 hours into free agency. There is plenty that can and will be done before it's over.

I also want the qb. Again, I am saying these losses make us less talented overall which is a detriment to our team currently. I will be patient and see the final results.

[skinsfaninok]

Washington so far has lost:

- Brandon Scherff
- Tim Settle
- JD McKissic

[EdmundDorf]

Yes, but we've signed Apke......

[Chief X_Phackter]

If we roll into the season with the current roster - I'll give you detrimental. Right now, it's just dudes taking more money than this franchise believes they are worth to the team they are trying to build.

I'll reserve judgment for when free agency and the draft are over. It's just so early to be too critical.

[EdmundDorf]

Nicki Jhabvala
@NickiJhabvala
Was told Washington did not make an offer to try to keep McKissic.

Interesting, I thought JDM was our first priority. Is our FO just trying to be too cute? ie "get back to us when you receive an offer and we can talk" That attitude can make people think they are not wanted

[EdmundDorf]

Originally Posted by EdmundDorf

Nicki Jhabvala
@NickiJhabvala
Was told Washington did not make an offer to try to keep McKissic.

Interesting, I thought JDM was our first priority. Is our FO just trying to be too cute? ie "get back to us when you receive an offer and we can talk" That attitude can make people think they are not wanted

My original point

[Chief X_Phackter]

Maybe he did get back to them and they decided not to match or beat the offer - hence they did not make an offer.

[EdmundDorf]

Originally Posted by Chief X_Phackter

Maybe he did get back to them and they decided not to match or beat the offer - hence they did not make an offer.

Maybe, but that is a dangerous game which doesn't make people feel wanted, so they just sign elsewhere

[EdmundDorf]

Originally Posted by Chief X_Phackter

Maybe he did get back to them and they decided not to match or beat the offer - hence they did not make an offer.

Don't like to toot my own horn (much) but ......
Ben Standig
@BenStandig
·
42m
J.D. McKissic is headed to Buffalo after Washington let the RB test free agency. That much is apparent. However, the Commanders believed their opportunity to match an offer would come. From the view of a source close to the situation, it did not.