Scud's Studs (Week 6 vs. Eagles)

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by 44ever

I thought D. Hall played solid and made a great play to give us an opportunity for a comeback.

Well, that's one way to put it. It ignores that Vince Young threw it right to him and he didn't return it anywhere, but at least you're right on the fact that it opened the door for a comeback part.

[mooby]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

Well, that's one way to put it. It ignores that Vince Young threw it right to him and he didn't return it anywhere, but at least you're right on the fact that it opened the door for a comeback part.

I don't think he played that great. On that big completion to maclin he went for the pick instead of just trying to bat it down. Of course that's the gambler in him, sometimes he'll make the play and sometimes he won't. But yesterday was an average game for him. His pick was the result of Vince Young not being up to game speed and making a careless throw as the result of pressure.

[Chico23231]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

Well, that's one way to put it. It ignores that Vince Young threw it right to him and he didn't return it anywhere, but at least you're right on the fact that it opened the door for a comeback part.

I mean he made the play. I sure if you scroll through the games yesterday you find similar plays where the defense dont make that play on a errand throw. Bigger props to Laron getting over VY to cause the bad pass.

[CrazyCanuck]

Not many studs this week...

- Gano - love him

- Rocca - love him

- Beck - was impressed, he does all the things that Rex doesn't, I'm a fan

- Atogwe - the only guy that understands how to tackle Vick

[44ever]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

Well, that's one way to put it. It ignores that Vince Young threw it right to him and he didn't return it anywhere, but at least you're right on the fact that it opened the door for a comeback part.

Thanks.

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

I mean he made the play. I sure if you scroll through the games yesterday you find similar plays where the defense dont make that play on a errand throw. Bigger props to Laron getting over VY to cause the bad pass.

Fair enough. Execution > not executing.

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by mooby

I don't think he played that great. On that big completion to maclin he went for the pick instead of just trying to bat it down. Of course that's the gambler in him, sometimes he'll make the play and sometimes he won't. But yesterday was an average game for him. His pick was the result of Vince Young not being up to game speed and making a careless throw as the result of pressure.

I don't even think it was mutually exclusive between batting it down and getting two hands on it in an attempt to intercept it.

I was actually a bit surprised Hall didn't make that. He closed really quickly and Maclin didn't come back to the football and use his body. That was as frustrating a play as any of the Rex turnovers. If you get in that kind of position, you have to make the play.

Luckily for Hall, Kevin Barnes was terrible again, so we still need him.

[44ever]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

I don't even think it was mutually exclusive between batting it down and getting two hands on it in an attempt to intercept it.

I was actually a bit surprised Hall didn't make that. He closed really quickly and Maclin didn't come back to the football and use his body. That was as frustrating a play as any of the Rex turnovers. If you get in that kind of position, you have to make the play.

Luckily for Hall, Kevin Barnes was terrible again, so we still need him.

All I said was Hall had a solid game and made a great play. I get you don't like Hall.

I still think he played well and gave the team a chance to turn it around. Maybe Hall keeps getting "lucky"...

[GMScud]

Originally Posted by 44ever

All I said was Hall had a solid game and made a great play. I get you don't like Hall.

I still think he played well and gave the team a chance to turn it around. Maybe Hall keeps getting "lucky"...

I don't know man... Hall gets beat too much for my liking. His saving grace is that he does have a good nose for the ball. But his coverage skills are nothing overly special.

[Bucket]

Oh Lord... Someone mention D. Hall didn't they? We all know G Tripp senses D. Halls names like a pig on poop.

D Hall is having a good year. He's made a lot of plays for us. The INT on Sunday was pretty easy, and expected from D. Hall...

Hatters gonna Hat

[12thMan]

I know folks might get their panties in a bunch, but I think D.Hall is have a better season than Nnamadi.

[Gary84Clark]

Originally Posted by 12thMan

I know folks might get their panties in a bunch, but I think D.Hall is have a better season than Nnamadi.

He had that pick how did he miss that?

[Chico23231]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

I don't even think it was mutually exclusive between batting it down and getting two hands on it in an attempt to intercept it.

I was actually a bit surprised Hall didn't make that. He closed really quickly and Maclin didn't come back to the football and use his body. That was as frustrating a play as any of the Rex turnovers. If you get in that kind of position, you have to make the play.

Luckily for Hall, Kevin Barnes was terrible again, so we still need him.

Barnes best fit maybe playing behind OJ Atowge at FS. Atowge has strung together several games now after a shaky start, playing pretty well. Barnes is a super liability in man to man...which is not good for our system.

[Meks]

Originally Posted by mlmpetert

Yeah Gano is looking good this season. I kind of wish we let him kick that 55-56 yarder after the delay of game.

agree 100%

[pg86]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

I know we are not looking ahead yet but after that loss yesterday, I still feel like we can go to Carolina and win. In the past, Id say no way, but this team has a different feel. Of course I feel alot better knowing that Becks would be starting.

I wish Shanahan would just announce him the starter already