2022 Commanders off season thread part 1

[Chico23231]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

I just don’t trust Pickett, I think he was a one year wonder.

Corral is good but he’s injury prone. Misses games every year In college.

I can see why Ron would go after Jimmy G, he knows this class will be a project class. We don’t have time to “hope”

Yeah Jimmy isn’t elite but he’s better than Heineke.

We have to be realistic as a fan base. Will we really trade a fortune for Russell Wilson? I don’t think Ron will. I hope he does but he’s huge on keeping draft capital.

Is Carson Wentz a possibility?
Jameis Winston?

If I’m drafting a QB I’m picking Willis Or Howell.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Do you really think Willis could develop into a legit QB? I have a really hard time with that. I think Ridder or Howell are better prospects and you could in the second or move back later in first if possible

[Chief X_Phackter]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

Do you really think Willis could develop into a legit QB? I have a really hard time with that. I think Ridder or Howell are better prospects and you could in the second or move back later in first if possible

I think I am in agreement with you. They all have flaws, some more glaring than others, but I really don't want them to use the 11th pick on any of the QBs in this draft (or Jimmy G).

You could land a really good WR, CB, or even O-lineman at 11 instead of reaching for a QB. Ridder in the 2nd would be nice.

Fact is, Mac Jones was the least favored QB of the five picked in the 1st round last year, and he turned out to be the most impressive out of them all. Davis Mills in the 3rd was probably as impressive, with less of a supporting cast.

No reason to waste that pick at 11 on a QB, not this year.

[jamf]

Weak draft class or not, Garappolo is not worth a 1st and a new 30+mil per year contract.

Rookie contracts are team friendly. They need to go with a rookie QB.

[punch it in]

If they give up a first for him ill throw in the towel on this team. He is propped up by that defense, and run game. If he were our quarterback this past year we are no better and no worse. Id rather watch TH for a cheaper price and keep the first. I’ve waited this many years for a quarterback I can wait one more for a real one without panicking and throwing away picks and money for this guy.

[MTK]

Originally Posted by punch it in

If they give up a first for him ill throw in the towel on this team. He is propped up by that defense, and run game. If he were our quarterback this past year we are no better and no worse. Id rather watch TH for a cheaper price and keep the first. I’ve waited this many years for a quarterback I can wait one more for a real one without panicking and throwing away picks and money for this guy.

I think you're kidding yourself if you don't think Jimmy G would be a big upgrade over TH. I'm not even a big fan of JG, and I think this says more about how mediocre TH is, but JG would definitely make us instantly much more competitive. Would I give up a first rounder for him? Hell no.

[Chico23231]

Originally Posted by MTK

I think you're kidding yourself if you don't think Jimmy G would be a big upgrade over TH. I'm not even a big fan of JG, and I think this says more about how mediocre TH is, but JG would definitely make us instantly much more competitive. Would I give up a first rounder for him? Hell no.

The problem is the Alex Smith double whammy…the trade AND the contract. What are you gonna commit to both of these?

[MTK]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

The problem is the Alex Smith double whammy…the trade AND the contract. What are you gonna commit to both of these?

Yeah not much, I was just talking strictly about his abilities vs TH. I'm not a big fan of JG at all but he's definitely an upgrade. I'm definitely not interested in giving up significant assets and committing to him with a big extension.

The Carson Wentz situation is much more interesting to me.

[punch it in]

Originally Posted by MTK

I think you're kidding yourself if you don't think Jimmy G would be a big upgrade over TH. I'm not even a big fan of JG, and I think this says more about how mediocre TH is, but JG would definitely make us instantly much more competitive. Would I give up a first rounder for him? Hell no.

Upgrade? Yes. Big upgrade? Idk. Im just saying ill take TH, the cash, and the first over Jimmy and wait one more year to see what is available in the way of quarterbacks if those were my two options,….

[skinsfanthru&thru]

Originally Posted by punch it in

Upgrade? Yes. Big upgrade? Idk. Im just saying ill take TH, the cash, and the first over Jimmy and wait one more year to see what is available in the way of quarterbacks if those were my two options,….

Same, we aren’t saying TH4 isn’t better than Jimmy G, but Jimmy G ain’t worth the pick and cash only to maybe result in one or at most probably two more wins than TH4 and either a rookie gamble this year or holding off for next year.

But that doesn’t compare to the ridiculousness of the Chase Young to Detroit for Goff rumor. That’s hands down one of the dumbest trade rumors I’ve ever heard of before lol.

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by punch it in

If they give up a first for him ill throw in the towel on this team. He is propped up by that defense, and run game. If he were our quarterback this past year we are no better and no worse. Id rather watch TH for a cheaper price and keep the first. I’ve waited this many years for a quarterback I can wait one more for a real one without panicking and throwing away picks and money for this guy.

He's in the tier of Cousins IMO, Give him a good line and Run game and he can win

[punch it in]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

He's in the tier of Cousins IMO, Give him a good line and Run game and he can win

I think KC is better. Jimmy has a very limited sample size, and it’s nothing special. He is gonna cash out undeservedly and should give half of it to his oline and rb’s back in SF. Lol

[KI Skins Fan]

Originally Posted by punch it in

I think KC is better. Jimmy has a very limited sample size, and it’s nothing special. He is gonna cash out undeservedly and should give half of it to his oline and rb’s back in SF. Lol

No truer words have ever been said.

[Chief X_Phackter]

Teams overpay for QBs. That's just the way it is. Desperate teams are even more prone to overpay - and this team is in that category. I'm not going to allow myself to be surprised that they overpaid for whoever the QB is next year.

[ArizonaSkinFan]

Jimmy G is a version of Alex Smith who isn't afraid to throw downfield. Washington can win with that. San Francisco has gone on record saying they aren't moving him if they don't get what they want. Could just be posturing not sure

Jimmy G vs Winston? Hmmm interesting. I would take either instead of reaching on one of this years rookies.

[ArizonaSkinFan]

Good opinions on the QB situation in this thread. All are valid.

The more I think about it I would go with Winston because he is a free agent and we wouldn't have to give up a pick. If you love Pickett or Coral or Willis draft them also and the QB situation is resolved for awhile.

If you don't love one of the QBs go linebacker or another position of need.