Tom "Iceman" Brady

[wilsowilso]

Peyton Manning's career playoff record is 5-6! Pretty mediocre for pressure situations especially seeing as how two of those five wins are from this year when he has been god awful!

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by wilsowilso

Peyton Manning's career playoff record is 5-6! Pretty mediocre for pressure situations especially seeing as how two of those five wins are from this year when he has been god awful!

Yeah, thats worse than I would expect from Manning, but what happens during the game is more significant in predicting future games than what the outcome was. So he lost six game...why should I think he'll ever lose again?

(Even though that last question is rhetorical, I still want you to answer it. If you can, that means we are at least on the same page.)

[wilsowilso]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

Yeah, thats worse than I would expect from Manning, but what happens during the game is more significant in predicting future games than what the outcome was. So he lost six game...why should I think he'll ever lose again?

(Even though that last question is rhetorical, I still want you to answer it. If you can, that means we are at least on the same page.)

I'm sure I have no idea what in the world you are rambling on about. Can you please translate this post for me? I guess this means we are not on the same page.

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by wilsowilso

I'm sure I have no idea what in the world you are rambling on about. Can you please translate this post for me? I guess this means we are not on the same page.

His record is 5-6. Fact. Does this mean he will win every playoff game the rest of his career? Does this mean that he will lose every playoff game the rest of his career? Basically, just tell me why his record of 5-6 in the playoff has significance to you.

If you are comparing it to Brady's 12-1 record, again we are getting into team statistics which have very little bearing on how good an individual is.

If you are trying to prove a different point with 5-6, please explain to me one more time what that point is.

[wilsowilso]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

His record is 5-6. Fact. Does this mean he will win every playoff game the rest of his career? Does this mean that he will lose every playoff game the rest of his career? Basically, just tell me why his record of 5-6 in the playoff has significance to you.

If you are comparing it to Brady's 12-1 record, again we are getting into team statistics which have very little bearing on how good an individual is.

If you are trying to prove a different point with 5-6, please explain to me one more time what that point is.

You're... you're crazy man. I like you, but you're crazy... "Frank the Tank"

[GiantsSuck703]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

His record is 5-6. Fact. Does this mean he will win every playoff game the rest of his career? Does this mean that he will lose every playoff game the rest of his career? Basically, just tell me why his record of 5-6 in the playoff has significance to you.

If you are comparing it to Brady's 12-1 record, again we are getting into team statistics which have very little bearing on how good an individual is.

If you are trying to prove a different point with 5-6, please explain to me one more time what that point is.

I dont get your argument, your basically saying that no matter how many clutch games Tom Brady has won that in your mind its discredited because his defense helped him win those games, although you then say that its Peyton Mannings defense, not his awful play in big games that has kept him from winning superbowls. Which to me, means your using your extremely obvious bias towards Peyton as your excuse for him being the better player. Your wrong, this isnt a matter of opinion, your just flat out wrong, Tom Brady has won the meaningless games and hes won the important games, hes a gamer and a former sixth round pick who had all the odds against him when he came into the league and basically took it over, hes not the most physically gifted QB, but hes a great leader and will carve up defenses like its nothing, i have seen nothing from Peyton Manning that makes me believe hes better than the 3-time superbowl champion Tom Brady.

[wolfeskins]

there is a poll question on redskins.com that asks "if you were a GM starting a team who would be your pick at qb"

choices are brady, manning, breeze and grossman

brady is leading with 55.3 %
manning is 2nd with 29.6 %

[wolfeskins]

Originally Posted by wolfeskins

there is a poll question on redskins.com that asks "if you were a GM starting a team who would be your pick at qb"

choices are brady, manning, breeze and grossman

brady is leading with 55.3 %
manning is 2nd with 29.6 %

over 55 % of skins fans can't be wrong

[wolfeskins]

Originally Posted by wolfeskins

there is a poll question on redskins.com that asks "if you were a GM starting a team who would be your pick at qb"

choices are brady, manning, breeze and grossman

brady is leading with 55.3 %
manning is 2nd with 29.6 %

over 8000 votes and brady still has a comanding lead.:tongue

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by wolfeskins

over 8000 votes and brady still has a comanding lead.:tongue

Behold the power of mass media!

Theres a reason polls aren't scientific.

[wilsowilso]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

Behold the power of mass media!

Theres a reason polls aren't scientific.

There is a reason that you are in the minority on this one. Just because you fail to see why doesn't make it any less significant.

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by wilsowilso

There is a reason that you are in the minority on this one. Just because you fail to see why doesn't make it any less significant.

What makes it less significant is ITS A FREAKIN POLL!!!

[wolfeskins]

Originally Posted by wolfeskins

over 8000 votes and brady still has a comanding lead.:tongue

over 10,000 votes and brady still has a comanding lead. :tongue :tongue

[Pocket$ $traight]

Can this thread be frozen after Manning and Harrison abuse them this weekend? Why in the hell has a post about some other team's QB been ongoing for so long?

[dmek25]

Brady is our eras Montana, and Manning = Dan Marino. its all in what you like. big time stats, or big time rings. to me, the rings are the things. but saying the patriots won those super bowls because of their defense, is an idiotic statement