Mark Sanchez at 13th?

[Lotus]

Originally Posted by 53Fan

Here's Kipers 2008 mock draft: Mel Kiper’s 2008 Mock NFL Draft reviewed | myMockDrafts.com He gets some things right and he's privy to a lot of information but his word is hardly gospel.

Excellent link 53. By my count he got 7 picks right (less than 25%). He also had 6 picks in the first round who actually did not go until the second round, which shows his talent evaluation skills often are not shared by NFL front offices.

[RedskinMike]

Originally Posted by Lotus

Excellent link 53. By my count he got 7 picks right (less than 25%). He also had 6 picks in the first round who actually did not go until the second round, which shows his talent evaluation skills often are not shared by NFL front offices.

Two of which were Malcolm Kelly and Devin Thomas.

[tryfuhl]

Originally Posted by Lotus

Excellent link 53. By my count he got 7 picks right (less than 25%). He also had 6 picks in the first round who actually did not go until the second round, which shows his talent evaluation skills often are not shared by NFL front offices.

could just mean that somebody in that organization had something different in mind

I can hardly fault a guy for making those decisions, doubt many people could do much better.. you never know what's going on in the FO's of a team, if they're gonna draft for need or BPA or what, it's not the science that some people make it out to be, he's gotta mock it and of course he won't get it all right

[Lotus]

Originally Posted by tryfuhl

could just mean that somebody in that organization had something different in mind

I can hardly fault a guy for making those decisions, doubt many people could do much better.. you never know what's going on in the FO's of a team, if they're gonna draft for need or BPA or what, it's not the science that some people make it out to be, he's gotta mock it and of course he won't get it all right

Actually Kiper gets paid to talk to those FO folks and have some idea about what they have in mind. Otherwise ESPN is wasting the money that they pay him. Put differently, why should we read his mock drafts if he doesn't know any more than we do?

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by Lotus

Actually Kiper gets paid to talk to those FO folks and have some idea about what they have in mind. Otherwise ESPN is wasting the money that they pay him. Put differently, why should we read his mock drafts if he doesn't know any more than we do?

That is the great mock draft conundrum, is it not?

Kiper's been at it for 25 plus years, so he knows what he's talking about, but it's important to point out that his mock's don't get historically more accurate with time. He's not working with insider information. He's working off his own player grades, and his personal interpretation of team behavior, which means that he has to take into account what he believes is and is not a smokescreen.

We do know that Vinny heavily values his input on draft grades. But there's no reason to believe that he got Vinny to cough up our draft strategy in exchange. That would be pretty criminal, and thusly, unlikely to have occurred.

If every team made their draft board public, Mock Drafts would be very easy and informative. The rampant speculation around this time of year tends to drain their value. You can mock a fantasy football draft with 300% more accuracy than you can hit the NFL draft.

There's reason to think we're interested in Sanchez, but not a lot of reason to trade up for him. If we were just going to take best available quarterback at No. 13, there would have been no reason to have the closed door meeting with Campbell.

[T.O.Killa]

Originally Posted by Lotus

Excellent link 53. By my count he got 7 picks right (less than 25%). He also had 6 picks in the first round who actually did not go until the second round, which shows his talent evaluation skills often are not shared by NFL front offices.

I am not saying that his final mock is different, but the mock that is shown was probably updated many times.

[53Fan]

Originally Posted by T.O.Killa

I am not saying that his final mock is different, but the mock that is shown was probably updated many times.

You may be right, but that's another reason to take his pick with a grain of salt. I have no problem with Kiper, he doe's the best job he can with what he has to work with, but I find his opinion a little more ventriloquist than others of his profession.

[Chico23231]

Sanchez at this spot would be another poor decision by the front office. With such enormous holes at OLB, DE and on the OL, how could they be thinking this right now? Better QB crop coming out next year if they want to go this route. We can win with Jason now, I'd say trade out of this pick, pick up more picks to address our needs...and forget about Sanchez, the guy really isnt that good for a 13th pick...........

[53Fan]

Is anyone else hoping the interest in Sanchez is just the Redskins trying to get a trade partner to trade down with?

[GridIron26]

Originally Posted by 53Fan

Is anyone else hoping the interest in Sanchez is just the Redskins trying to get a trade partner to trade down with?

That's what I'm hoping for

[53Fan]

The reason I posted the link was to show why, I for one, take what he says with a grain of salt. Just because he says it, doesn't make it so. If more than a couple of these guys say the same thing, there may be some merit to it. But Kiper is not the know-all, end-all of the NFL draft. NOBODY is sure who is going to pick who, except the guys making the picks. And even they don't know until they see how the draft falls. Nothings wrong with an educated guess, but it is what it is, a guess.

[Eknox]

Couldn't have said it better myself 53

[MTK]

Was it Kiper that also said he thinks the Skins could trade out of #13 if Sanchez is there?

[skins89moss]

Well if we use the #13 pick on Sanchez i will be smoking Hot. I think we use our 13th pick on a player thats has to start. I think this has got to be a smoke screen to get other teams to believe that we may take Sanchez. Hopefully a team that really needs a QB will want to trade into our spot and we can pick up some extra picks.I dont trust Junior QB's to come in an make an immediate impact. Please Vinny i hope you got this cause we are pulling for you to get it right.

[MeanEvilSkin]

If Danny was watching SortsCenter this morning, we're taking Sanchez. That is, until they showcase another player next week. And then...