East champs!!! You like that???!!!

[Giantone]

Originally Posted by punch it in

Either way - whether he is canned or not - turmoil certainly works when talking about the Gints, Boys, or Birds rite now. Don't take it too hard remember - this is a Redskins site - we are very familiar with the word!

LOL , I realize what site I'm on and I appreciate it ,I just think the Giants are in a whole different(and better) situation then the Cowboys or the Eagles.

[punch it in]

Originally Posted by Giantone

LOL , I realize what site I'm on and I appreciate it ,I just think the Giants are in a whole different(and better) situation then the Cowboys or the Eagles.

Yeah. I think you are downplaying the way the Giants lost so many of their games this year though. Countless mind numbing decisions in the final minutes. That has too much to do with coaching to blame it all on personnel. Either way would you agree Reese has to go?

[Giantone]

Originally Posted by punch it in

Either way would you agree Reese has to go?

Yes, I said it weeks ago.

[calia]

Originally Posted by Giantone

LOL , I realize what site I'm on and I appreciate it ,I just think the Giants are in a whole different(and better) situation then the Cowboys or the Eagles.

Eagles, yes. Dallas, perhaps not.

Dallas has a better O-line, better D-line, comparable QB (Eli and Romo both can be dominant, and both can throw 4 picks on occasion), comparable WRs (although I would probably give the Giants the nod there as I think ODB is better than Dez), comparable RBs (neither team in great shape on that), and comparable on special teams (with Dallas getting the slight nod because their kicker is better). But given the importance of winning at the line of scrimmage, I would say Dallas has better personnel, and would be a better situation for a new coach (at least initially).

The GM situations are both bad. At least the NYG can improve there because the owner isn't also the GM.