Should we be drafting Tua???

[AnonEmouse]

Its not faulting by injury, its the frequency and type. Regardless of potential and displayed ability some injuries can and do shorten careers. Regardless of said ability teams and coaches have to take jjnto account the potential availability of a drafted based on historic injuries. Guice dropped down for good reason as proven last 2 years, and maybe the worst is over, but you would never have taken him with a top 25 pick based on his history. So why is Tua special? Because he's a QB? Sorry, its too high a risk for most organisations that have a competent QB already on the roster. Haskins isn't proven either way but he's competent and fit right now. With other needs why risk the whole applecart on Tua?

We do need a backup, hopefully a competent vet, but right now we need a defence that can take the pressure off the O as it develops. CY or trading down and getting Simmons and maybe Okudah makes far more sense than risking it all on Tua.

[NYCskinfan82]

Every QB is different. Please explain we moved on from RG3 mainly because he couldn't stay healthy. Now you want to sign Tua. I've followed Tua think he's a great QB but the pros hit harder.

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by NYCskinfan82

Every QB is different. Please explain we moved on from RG3 mainly because he couldn't stay healthy. Now you want to sign Tua. I've followed Tua think he's a great QB but the pros hit harder.

I'm saying if Tua is the clear cut better QB than Dwayne, you consider it. If you don't have a QB, Chase Young doesn't mean jack... Ask Khalil Mack, Von Miller etc.

[mooby]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

I'm saying if Tua is the clear cut better QB than Dwayne, you consider it. If you don't have a QB, Chase Young doesn't mean jack... Ask Khalil Mack, Von Miller etc.

It really all depends on everyone's personal opinion of Haskins. All of the haters are acting like his last two games are irrelevant to the overall opinion.

Haskins has been in the building since Rivera got here, obviously doing everything he can prove he wants it. There is literally no reason to believe Rivera doesn't like Haskins (if you've studied the NFL long enough to know coaches like to keep their intentions vague in the media for a reason).

[CRedskinsRule]

Originally Posted by mooby

It really all depends on everyone's personal opinion of Haskins. All of the haters are acting like his last two games are irrelevant to the overall opinion.

Haskins has been in the building since Rivera got here, obviously doing everything he can prove he wants it. There is literally no reason to believe Rivera doesn't like Haskins (if you've studied the NFL long enough to know coaches like to keep their intentions vague in the media for a reason).

I disagree that it depends on opinions. Just from a draft and team building perspective, if you draft 2 qb's in the first round the opportunity cost is huge.

If you did draft Tua, and it's a true competition, and Haskins wins - you gave up the opportunity to draft Chase Young, or potential trade value of the #2 spot, which makes the decision even daftier, assume we could get two firsts and a 3rd for the 2nd spot, that is immense draft capital lost, for a qb bust. (again assuming Haskins wins the competition)

If you draft Tua, have the competition, and he wins, you still gave up the potential game changer in Chase Young, but also effectively gave up 3 potential first round picks in Haskins plus 2 firsts in any potential trade.

Finally, even if RR believes Haskins isn't a franchise qb, the lost value this year in simply giving up on him is huge in the development of the team as a whole unit. Clearly Haskins has made efforts to show he has heard what RR is preaching, and he has acted accordingly. If RR turns around and says thanks but no, without Haskins having had a chance to show very much on the field, what would that do to RR's message of you do what I say, and it doesn't work, I shoulder the blame. It destroys it.

Bottomline there is always smoke at this tiem of year, but throwing away a talented qb for the shiny object qb is not going to make this a better team.

[KI Skins Fan]

I feel strongly both ways.

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by KI Skins Fan

I feel strongly both ways.

So lets say tonight is draft night, I'm putting you on the spot.. Who do u take?

[MTK]

I think we should draft Tua, sign Brady and Rivers, and let them all fight it out with Haskins in a steel cage match

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by MTK

I think we should draft Tua, sign Brady and Rivers, and let them all fight it out with Haskins in a steel cage match

At the rate we are all going, we may be doing this for Toilet paper

[KI Skins Fan]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

So lets say tonight is draft night, I'm putting you on the spot.. Who do u take?

I'd have to take Chase Young.

[sdskinsfan2001]

Originally Posted by MTK

I think we should draft Tua, sign Brady and Rivers, and let them all fight it out with Haskins in a steel cage match

I like it!

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by KI Skins Fan

I'd have to take Chase Young.

Me too honestly

[NYCskinfan82]

Originally Posted by KI Skins Fan

I'd have to take Chase Young.

Me three.

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

I'm saying if Tua is the clear cut better QB than Dwayne, you consider it. If you don't have a QB, Chase Young doesn't mean jack... Ask Khalil Mack, Von Miller etc.

Von Miller has a SB trophy and that was in spite of Peyton Manning more so than because of him. I'll give you Khalil but Trubisky sucks and they even went 12-4.

[SunnySide]

Apologies if I already posted this, been a crazy busy day at work.
----------------

Chase Young is my strong preference for the no. 2 pick.

If we did draft Tua, I could talk myself into liking the pick. The ultimate goal of any franchise is to find a franchise QB and drafting Tua would give us 2 chances at that. I think haskins deserves at least this year to prove what he is but, if I had to label him today, I think he is more of a 10-15 ranked QB vs a top 10. And thats fine, you can chase SBs with a 10-15 rank QB as long as you have a strong complimentary team and game plan.

Tua appears to be a higher ceiling QB to me, if healthy. But this discussion re drafting Tua just seems like normal "what if" lets talk hypotheticals off season talk.

Young all day