Another D.Hall Thread.

[12thMan]

Sorry, I don't usually start frivolous threads but I had to get this off my chest. Pro Football Focus rated D.Hall 184 out of 199 cornerbacks that saw regular action last year. Get this Kevin Barnes was ranked 187.

I might be drinking the Kool Aid, but I'd still rank Hall as a top 15-17 corner in this league. He's had his ups and downs, yes, but beyond the regular All Pro corners, I'm not convinced that DeAngelo Hall isn't a top 15 corner in this league.

Who here disagrees with that and why?

[12thMan]

Oh..I know this an annual argument around here, so why not have it again this year.

[mbedner3420]

Unless you're telling me he is cut in favor of a better starting CB, I'm not interested lol

[Chico23231]

Blame Danny Boy and Vinny, they gave D Hall the money which should have been Carlos's extention. So we are stuck with him while Carlos is making pro bowls, playing on the premier NFL defense. oh well

[Bubba305-ST21-]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

Blame Danny Boy and Vinny, they gave D Hall the money which should have been Carlos's extention. So we are stuck with him while Carlos is making pro bowls, playing on the premier NFL defense. oh well

Hindsight is always 20/20. I don't recall anyone calling to extend Carlos everyone just complained about his drops his overall play not just his drops improved last year in SanFran. Dhall is far from great but he is a starter for us we have no better options out there for us right now, this will be addressed next year

[mooby]

Originally Posted by Bubba305-ST21-

Hindsight is always 20/20. I don't recall anyone calling to extend Carlos everyone just complained about his drops his overall play not just his drops improved last year in SanFran. Dhall is far from great but he is a starter for us we have no better options out there for us right now, this will be addressed next year

I would've extended him for a couple years at decent money but not big money like he wanted. If he had gone to the doctor while he played here and gotten his vision problem fixed as well as his catching problem fixed I would've given him a big money deal after that. That was his only problem. As soon as he left here he decided to get his vision checked out and (shock of all shockers) the a-hole needed contacts. Boom! catching problem fixed. Either way he's in his early 30's now so even if we had given him a big money deal I wouldn't have made it like 7 years or anything.

[Chico23231]

Originally Posted by Bubba305-ST21-

Hindsight is always 20/20. I don't recall anyone calling to extend Carlos everyone just complained about his drops his overall play not just his drops improved last year in SanFran. Dhall is far from great but he is a starter for us we have no better options out there for us right now, this will be addressed next year

always liked carlos, always said his game was tight. didnt like his mouth, but i understand why he was pissed.

[skinsnut]

Originally Posted by Bubba305-ST21-

Hindsight is always 20/20. I don't recall anyone calling to extend Carlos

I sure did.
I thought Carlos was solid...yeah he couldn't catch...but that's why he plays defense, have you seen the preseason, out entire defense has that issue.

Also,
I am sick of the DHall crap...I hate the way he runs his mouth and misses tackles....he blows coverage but mostly covers well. he obviously sucks as a nickle back and safety...why?....he can't tackle.

[CrazyCanuck]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

Blame Danny Boy and Vinny, they gave D Hall the money which should have been Carlos's extention. So we are stuck with him while Carlos is making pro bowls, playing on the premier NFL defense. oh well

Right on brother.

It's ok, at least DHall can catch right?

[Evilgrin]

Originally Posted by 12thMan

Sorry, I don't usually start frivolous threads but I had to get this off my chest. Pro Football Focus rated D.Hall 184 out of 199 cornerbacks that saw regular action last year. Get this Kevin Barnes was ranked 187.

I might be drinking the Kool Aid, but I'd still rank Hall as a top 115-117 corner in this league. He's had his ups and downs, yes, but beyond the regular All Pro corners, I'm not convinced that DeAngelo Hall isn't a top 15 corner in this league.

Who here disagrees with that and why?

I agree with this, sneaky edit

[Ruhskins]

Wow. This really needed its own thread?

[The Goat]

Hall's reward/risk ratio per game is only positive if he creates at least one turnover IMO.

[MTK]

Top 15? Damn that kool aid must be sweet.

If PFF has him 184, I tend to believe it.

Is there a link to the entire list, I'd like to check it out.

[12thMan]

Haha..@Matty.

[Slingin Sammy 33]

Don't see Hall as one of the worst, but certainly not Top 15-17. He's #2 CB caliber IMO. Gives up way too much cushion (off-man) and can't recover the way he could a few years ago, also not physical enough to press, questionable tackling, questionable instincts. Without the top-end speed he had when he first came in....he's not the same guy.