Quote:
Originally Posted by Schneed10
Yeah I think your first problem is that you seem to think Robert Griffin is God's gift. I don't see that. I see that in Luck, but not Griffin.
|
I don't think anyone is "God's gift" and I'm not sure what the point of a lame comment like that is. If you don't like him as a prospect, that's fine. I do, as do plenty of other people. We can disagree, but rest assured, I don't need you to tell me what "my problem" is.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Schneed10
You also seem to think Peyton is in some sort of decline. That's the biggest source of disagreement between the two of us.
|
Manning's passer ratings by age:
28- 121.1
29- 104.1
30- 101
31- 98
32- 95
33- 99.9
34- 91.9
A pretty clear downward trajectory there, and that number for his last year would have been good for only 7th best in the NFC this season.
People decline physically as they get older. It's not exactly controversial to say that. And taking a year off and having multiple surgeries aren't exactly elixirs for that.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Schneed10
As for cap space, no, not even close. There are not THAT many good ways to spend $35 - $45 friggin million in cap space. Nobody makes that many free agent acquisitions and lives to tell the tale. See: Cerrato, Vinny.
|
Ah, so once there was a terrible GM who didn't know what he was doing, so all Free Agent spending is bad. Brilliant. Does that also apply to Gibbs' Washington-Springs-Griffin-Daniels-Moss spending spree that was the basis for two playoff runs? How about the Patriots first Super Bowl win after signing about 20 FAs? There are smart ways and dumb ways to spend money, just like there are dumb ways to do most anything.
For the record, why don't you look at GTripp's breakdown of our cap space. People keep throwing these numbers around and thinking that we are going to have trouble figuring out what to do with all the cap space. Once we re-sign our own and our draft picks, that space turns into a much more pedestrian number.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Schneed10
And yes, in the end Griffin is a dice roll.
|
Thank goodness we don't have a FO that thinks of things so simplistically.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Schneed10
People have thought extremely highly of a lot of quarterbacks. Mark Sanchez and Matt Ryan were both extremely productive, highly regarded, and high character guys. One can't muster anything better than mediocre production, and the other disappears in road games and come playoff time. You just don't know.
|
Yeah, I'll take Ryan and his future any day, thank you.
Sanchez had only one year of starting in college, which is a huge red flag. He also had an arrest on his record, and other maturity questions.