Ive always been on the Brady side when it comes to Brady vs. Manning. I think he is/will be the best qb of all time. In a couple years he could make a solid argument for best player of all time, but i think thats a little premature.
The thing about Manning proving hes the MVP is a little off imo. Indy was gonna have a tough time making the playoffs this year regardless of his injury, the team is just not as talented all around as it has been in year's past. Hopefully Manning will be back next year and both players will be around for few more years so the Brady vs Manning debate will keep going.
Also youre lucky Brady decided to start this year off with a bang. If he had waited until next year you wouldnt be able to resurrect this thread, as 5 years is the established cut off:
http://www.thewarpath.net/redskins-l...er-fans-3.html