Commanders Post at The Warpath - View Single Post

GTripp0012 · 02-01-2011, 06:26 PM

Here, to me is the argument against Hall's INTs:

His 11 Washington Redskin picks (excluding the Hail Mary vs. Kolb) came against the following QBs:

2008 Week 11 -- Romo (w/broken thumb)
2008 Week 12 -- E. Manning
2009 Week 1 -- E. Manning
2009 Week 4 -- J. Johnson
2009 Week 5 -- Delhomme
2009 Week 10 -- C. Simms
2010 Week 7 -- Cutler
2010 Week 7 -- Cutler
2010 Week 7 -- Cutler
2010 Week 7 -- Cutler
2010 Week 8 -- Stafford

My point is: it's not like the Redskins just haven't played great quarterbacks. We've seen Schaub, Peyton, Vick, Ryan, Rodgers, Romo, Eli, and McNabb while Hall's starting. He managed to get Eli twice (and Eli's no slouch though he will throw it up for grabs), but in the rest of the games against the best passers Hall was, in his best moments, a non-factor.

I mean, Carlos Rogers only has four picks in the last three seasons, but he's also gotten Warner and Schaub once each (with a horrible drop against Peyton). Against the most prolific QBs we've faced, Rogers -- not Hall -- has been the better playmaker.

02-01-2011, 06:26 PM	#169
GTripp0012 Living Legend Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: Evanston, IL Age: 37 Posts: 15,994	Re: D. Hall is our lone Pro Bowl selection Here, to me is the argument against Hall's INTs: His 11 Washington Redskin picks (excluding the Hail Mary vs. Kolb) came against the following QBs: 2008 Week 11 -- Romo (w/broken thumb) 2008 Week 12 -- E. Manning 2009 Week 1 -- E. Manning 2009 Week 4 -- J. Johnson 2009 Week 5 -- Delhomme 2009 Week 10 -- C. Simms 2010 Week 7 -- Cutler 2010 Week 7 -- Cutler 2010 Week 7 -- Cutler 2010 Week 7 -- Cutler 2010 Week 8 -- Stafford My point is: it's not like the Redskins just haven't played great quarterbacks. We've seen Schaub, Peyton, Vick, Ryan, Rodgers, Romo, Eli, and McNabb while Hall's starting. He managed to get Eli twice (and Eli's no slouch though he will throw it up for grabs), but in the rest of the games against the best passers Hall was, in his best moments, a non-factor. I mean, Carlos Rogers only has four picks in the last three seasons, but he's also gotten Warner and Schaub once each (with a horrible drop against Peyton). Against the most prolific QBs we've faced, Rogers -- not Hall -- has been the better playmaker. __________________ according to a source with knowledge of the situation.