Quote:
Originally Posted by jsarno
Not sure Finley should make the list. Certainly a good pitcher. His best years were from 89-93 (89 and 90 being by far his best), but from 94-02 he had exactly 1 sub 4.15 era season. Take away his two good years and he would have a 174-173 career record. You shouldn't be able to take away 2 years of a guy with a 17 year career and all of sudden he becomes average. I didn't calculate it, but I'm betting it would put his career mark over the 4.00 era if you took away those two season as well.
|
CF had a good career but he's not in the conversation. 200 W's, 3.8 ERA, good but not elite.