Re: Start John Beck Madness Thread
 

[quote=Mattyk;843503]Dumb idea. Even worse to even entertain the idea at 3-1.[/quote]

Since we didn't we're now 3 and 2. The writing was clearly on the wall that Rex was rapidly regressing.

Re: Start John Beck Madness Thread
 

BECK! End of story...

Re: Start John Beck Madness Thread
 

We have seen enough of Grossman. THis is not just on bad game. Time to move on. Beck looked better suited to move the sticks. I hope the Shananhan's do not think about going back to Grossman. Enough!

Re: Start John Beck Madness Thread
 

All the Grossman supporters can go to hell. No effing way he should start anymore period after that bullshit

Re: Start John Beck Madness Thread
 

Que a different placeholder.

Re: Start John Beck Madness Thread
 

I seriously can't see Grossman starting the rest of the season unless Beck starts imploding. You can't throw 4 INTs in a divisional matchup and expect to start the next game. Beck showed he can move in the pocket and step up, he's mobile, he plays unafraid. He's not the answer but he's no worse than Grossman.

Re: Start John Beck Madness Thread
 

[quote=DynamiteRave;847952]I seriously can't see Grossman starting the rest of the season unless Beck starts imploding. You can't throw 4 INTs in a divisional matchup and expect to start the next game. Beck showed he can move in the pocket and step up, he's mobile, he plays unafraid. He's not the answer [B]but he's no worse than Grossman[/B].[/quote]

He is better than Grossman....and that ain't saying much!
I will be pissed at Shanny if he goes back to Grossman next week. PISSED!

Re: Start John Beck Madness Thread
 

[quote=Mechanix544;847525]Would this qualify? Or would he have to be ABSOLUTELY COMPLETELY responsible for the Interceptions? Like walking up to Nate Allen and handing him the ball all wrapped up in philadelphia Eagles gift wrap?

Just wondering.....[/quote]

Yup. This qualifies. I had a disclaimer and I stand by it. Rex single handedly snuffed out any chance of victory. I gave him a pass on the first INT, but after that they were just horrible and he should not have even started the second half.

It's Beck job now and rightfullly so.

Re: Start John Beck Madness Thread
 

Now with the Oline missing our starting G, and we need to start shifting. There is NO WAY you can start Rex. Beck is more mobile and we are going to need his legs to make plays.

One example is the dropped pass of Stallworth. Beck made that play happen with his legs. Rex would of been run down from behind or something worse I fear.

Beck has a better ball. Rex and Beck both threw the SAME pass up the seam. Becks ball was tight and quick for a first down to Austin.

Rex threw a tight pass, but it lofted in the air and lacks zip like most of Rex's passes. So it resulted in a pass breakup

Re: Start John Beck Madness Thread
 

Again, I was never a Grossman "supporter" - I was a "don't mess with success" guy. Grossman just sucked beyond belief today. Horrible.

Re: Start John Beck Madness Thread
 

I dont hate grossman as much as I hate whichever shanahan decided let him pass so much in the first place. The eagles run defense is among the Worst in the league while their pass defense is one of the best. The run to pass ratio should have been 2:1

Re: Start John Beck Madness Thread
 

[quote=BigHairedAristocrat;848025][B]I dont hate grossman as much as I hate whichever shanahan decided let him pass so much in the first place.[/B] The eagles run defense is among the Worst in the league while their pass defense is one of the best. The run to pass ratio should have been 2:1[/quote]

or keep him after the second INT.

How good does Jason Campbell look right about now? Better than Grossman and Beck IMO.

[QUOTE=BigHairedAristocrat;848025]I dont hate grossman as much as I hate whichever shanahan decided let him pass so much in the first place. The eagles run defense is among the Worst in the league while their pass defense is one of the best. The run to pass ratio should have been 2:1[/QUOTE]

Easy to say. They were stacking up against our run and it was going nowhere. Couple that with two starting OLs out for the game. Again, easy to say.

Re: Start John Beck Madness Thread
 

[quote=hooskins;848030]How good does Jason Campbell look right about now? Better than Grossman and Beck IMO.[/quote]

We have not seen anything of Beck yet. We do not yet know for sure what we have in Beck. Hopefully we will see in the next week or two. It is too soon to make that comment.