Re: What is preventing Ike Hilliard and Gruden from replacing J. Doctson with Mo Harris?
 

[quote=sevier2;1206430]Harris has been playing plenty. My question to those of you who are saying we need to bench Doctson would be; [B]Who do you put in to replace him?[/B]

What other options do we have that are undoubtedly BETTER than what Doctson can provide? [B]If you're going to bench your first round pick you'd better be SURE there's an upgrade, not just "Maybe this guy can produce, we'll see.."[/B]

I agree, we need an upgrade in the WR department but as the roster stands right NOW, there isn't a whole lot sitting behind Doctson. Certainly not enough to warrant benching him.[/quote]

too many ppl think just like this. That his draft status should protect him. Bullshit. He's soft ass baby shit and can;t get off a jam to save his life. I'm all for the kid trying to improve but he's not exactly out performing anyone else... Also, wasn;t Doc a 2nd? or am i losing my shit cuz this franchise is in such shambles that I can;t tell the difference between my cousin and a turd?
(i'm fine with letting kirk go tho)

Re: What is preventing Ike Hilliard and Gruden from replacing J. Doctson with Mo Harris?
 

[quote=Meks;1206436]too many ppl think just like this. That his draft status should protect him. Bullshit. He's soft ass baby shit and can;t get off a jam to save his life. I'm all for the kid trying to improve but he's not exactly out performing anyone else... Also, wasn;t Doc a 2nd? or am i losing my shit cuz this franchise is in such shambles that I can;t tell the difference between my cousin and a turd?
(i'm fine with letting kirk go tho)[/quote]

I agree, draft status should have no bearing on who starts but you didn't answer my initial question.

[B]Who [/B]do you put in instead of him with our current roster? Who do you trot out there as your starting 3 without Doctson?

Crowder out wide, Quinn in the slot and Harris on the other side?? Assuming those guys can even get healthy...

Doctson is not living up to draft status, for sure. But god damn we have nothing else...

Re: What is preventing Ike Hilliard and Gruden from replacing J. Doctson with Mo Harris?
 

[quote=sevier2;1206439]I agree, draft status should have no bearing on who starts but you didn't answer my initial question.

[B]Who [/B]do you put in instead of him with our current roster? Who do you trot out there as your starting 3 without Doctson?

Crowder out wide, Quinn in the slot and Harris on the other side?? Assuming those guys can even get healthy...

Doctson is not living up to draft status, for sure. But god damn we have nothing else...[/quote]

Anyone!
Brian Quick, Floyd, or Harris.
Anything over 2 receptions and 30 yards is an improvement!

Re: What is preventing Ike Hilliard and Gruden from replacing J. Doctson with Mo Harris?
 

[quote=punch it in;1206404]Lol Mo Harris is a pro bowler now? Listen if the guy was absolutely lighting it up ie: the other undrafted players you mentioned than ok but when he is serviceable at best you better believe that they don’t want to bench a first round draft pick.[/quote]

No....Harris is not a pro bowler....but he is undrafted and has been more impressive than 1st rd pick Josh Doctson...through 8 games Doctson has only 19 receptions for a sour 190 yards....that is piss poor production for a WR the team invested a 1st rd pick on....he only had 40 catches for 550 yards last year....it doesn't matter where a player is drafted....or if he's drafted at all....what matters is the production that a player has....and Harris has done more in one game (10 receptions for 124 yards versus Atlanta) than Doctson has all season long...that's all I'm saying....

Re: What is preventing Ike Hilliard and Gruden from replacing J. Doctson with Mo Harris?
 

[quote=Meks;1206429]Blame the front office. It all relates back to mismanagement[/quote]

Exactly...!!!

Look at the 2016 1st rd draft results....into the 2nd round look at where the NYG drafted WR Sterling Shepard....Shepard has had a more productive career than Doctson and he's the #2 behind Beckum.....we can easily assume that Sterling Shepard (drafted 19 picks behind Doctson) could have been a 1st rd selection...GM Scott McCloughan should have known that Shepard was better at pick 21 in the 1st rd than Doctson was..

Re: What is preventing Ike Hilliard and Gruden from replacing J. Doctson with Mo Harris?
 

Mo Harris is a #4 WR on most rosters

Re: What is preventing Ike Hilliard and Gruden from replacing J. Doctson with Mo Harris?
 

[quote=skinsfaninok;1206448]Mo Harris is a #4 WR on most rosters[/quote]

He may be, but I swear if Harris was on the Pats they'd get production out of him. Look at what they're doing w/ Patterson.

Re: What is preventing Ike Hilliard and Gruden from replacing J. Doctson with Mo Harris?
 

[quote=skinsfan69;1206450]He may be, but I swear if Harris was on the Pats they'd get production out of him. Look at what they're doing w/ Patterson.[/quote]

O yeah but they would get production out of you and me too lol

Re: What is preventing Ike Hilliard and Gruden from replacing J. Doctson with Mo Harris?
 

I think the FO felt we had enough talent on the roster to put off signing any WR help this year. ON PAPER we still look pretty formidable. We've got Reed, Davis, Thompson, Crowder... They added Guice which would have been huge and A. Smith has generally utilized those positions (TE & RB) more so than his wide-outs.

Now that the production hasn't come from the TE's and Backfield our lack of talent at wideout has been exposed.

It's definitely an issue, but I still don't think shuffling in some JAG's is going to improve it. I'm afraid this is a problem that won't be fixed until the off-season.

Re: What is preventing Ike Hilliard and Gruden from replacing J. Doctson with Mo Harris?
 

[quote=skinsfan69;1206450]He may be, but I swear if Harris was on the Pats they'd get production out of him. Look at what they're doing w/ Patterson.[/quote]

And Doctson too.

Re: What is preventing Ike Hilliard and Gruden from replacing J. Doctson with Mo Harris?
 

[QUOTE=REDSKINS4ever;1206444]No....Harris is not a pro bowler....but he is undrafted and has been more impressive than 1st rd pick Josh Doctson...through 8 games Doctson has only 19 receptions for a sour 190 yards....that is piss poor production for a WR the team invested a 1st rd pick on....he only had 40 catches for 550 yards last year....it doesn't matter where a player is drafted....or if he's drafted at all....what matters is the production that a player has....and Harris has done more in one game (10 receptions for 124 yards versus Atlanta) than Doctson has all season long...that's all I'm saying....[/QUOTE]



I agree with you to be honest, but im not the FO with egg on my face, and im not paying these people so....

Re: What is preventing Ike Hilliard and Gruden from replacing J. Doctson with Mo Harris?
 

I needed to work in my shop so I listened to the game on the radio as I also did last Sunday. The radio broadcast team especially Cooley was brutal evaluating Mo Harris, saying he was always looking to lay down after catching the ball. My TV died yesterday and can't be watching videos with data capped satellite internet, so I have to trust the broadcast team. Is the guy obviously afraid of contact?

Re: What is preventing Ike Hilliard and Gruden from replacing J. Doctson with Mo Harris?
 

[quote=Buffalo Bob;1206944]I needed to work in my shop so I listened to the game on the radio as I also did last Sunday. The radio broadcast team especially Cooley was brutal evaluating Mo Harris, saying he was always looking to lay down after catching the ball. My TV died yesterday and can't be watching videos with data capped satellite internet, so I have to trust the broadcast team. Is the guy obviously afraid of contact?[/quote]

Harris is soft, but so is our entire WR group. Yesterday the announcers were saying "this team just has nobody to get separation" as I've said all yr watching tape. It's not all Alex's fault, yeah he has been very AVG. but he really has nobody to throw too.

Re: What is preventing Ike Hilliard and Gruden from replacing J. Doctson with Mo Harris?
 

[quote=NorCall11;1206396]im all for seeing more of this guy. i guess alex smith will ultimately decide.[/quote]

yeah... about that..

Re: What is preventing Ike Hilliard and Gruden from replacing J. Doctson with Mo Harris?
 

[quote=skinsfaninok;1206950]Harris is soft, but so is our entire WR group. Yesterday the announcers were saying "this team just has nobody to get separation" as I've said all yr watching tape. It's not all Alex's fault, yeah he has been very AVG. but he really has nobody to throw too.[/quote]

I don't know. WR's can and do create separation but QB's also create separation. Sure we don't have an elite WR but we do have good targets. Smith was too scared to throw the ball. That was the problem. I felt like I was watching Jason Campbell all over again.. I spent a decade defending Alex Smith when he was on other rosters but man.. the guy was terrified of making a mistake throwing it but sure would take a sack in a heartbeat.

I don't expect Colt to light 'em up, but I suspect the offense will look a little better under him if he can find a rhythm early. Get the running game working, give Colt some screens and 8-10 yard out routes and I'm betting he takes some shots. I was thrilled when we signed Alex but honestly I think we're in better hands with Colt. Try to steal an early lead, run the ball 35 times and limit Colt to 20-25 throws and I think we win tomorrow. Defense has to takeover this game and I think they'll come out ready to break the will of this Dallas team early.