Pat White or Sexxy Rexy

[Monkeydad]

Grossman could start for Buffalo, the Jets, Jacksonville and possibly Oakland if we let him go.

Even with the draft picks used on QBs recently in those places, they're all still a mess at the QB position.

White played more and was a lot more effective than I ever thought he'd be, but Rex is still a far better route to go. Our QB3 is better than some team's starters at this point...and better than a lot of backups.

Originally Posted by Mattyk

Would they give him a roster spot now though?

Big difference in giving a guy a look in training camp vs a regular season spot.

Around Week 12 they would give him a PS spot....preparing for us.

[Monkeydad]

Originally Posted by JoeRedskin

Pat White? Good for them. David Carr is their back-up. If David Carr was MY second string QB, I would be interested in just about anyone at the QB position.

Ryan Nassib.


They're trade him to a QB-desperate team in a couple of years, unless Eli gets annihilated and can't suit up.





p.s. Smooty...QB ratings are not percentages.

[JoeRedskin]

White is not eligible for the PS as he was a roster player his first year with Miami. If he was PS eligible, I would have NO problem with him occupying a spot on ours. It is really where he belongs at this point.

[Chico23231]

im callin it now, if PW gets cut, he finds a team quickly

[Monkeydad]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

im callin it now, if PW gets cut, he finds a team quickly

New England.

[JoeRedskin]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

im callin it now, if PW gets cut, he finds a team quickly

I think it likely also. However, let's watch the TBay game and see how he does. Still have not seen him throw a deep ball or something other than a slant or dig.

AND, it's not an "IF" he gets cut, it's a "WHEN" he gets cut.

[Ruhskins]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

im callin it now, if PW gets cut, he finds a team quickly

Arena League?

[FRPLG]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

im callin it now, if PW gets cut, he finds a team quickly

I think his play has earned him that for sure. He's not making this team though in any scenario.

[Chico23231]

I know one thing for sure, I'd take PW over Tebow all day long.

[FRPLG]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

I know one thing for sure, I'd take PW over Tebow all day long.

That's for damn sure.

[SmootSmack]

Originally Posted by Monkeydad

Ryan Nassib.


They're trade him to a QB-desperate team in a couple of years, unless Eli gets annihilated and can't suit up.





p.s. Smooty...QB ratings are not percentages.

Typo on my part. Got thrown off by sbxvii doing that

[JoeRedskin]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

I know one thing for sure, I'd take PW over Tebow all day long.

Not setting the bar particularly high there Chico my man. That's like saying "I'd take a bowl of partially cooked bland rice over a bowl of piping hot sh**".

Tebow's limitations in the QB spot make PW look like John Elway (okay, maybe more like Tony Romo - still, you catch my drift).

[Lotus]

I see PW and Tebow as basically the same level:

1) Neither can read an NFL defense
2) Neither can complete a pass for longer than 15 yards
3) Neither throws with particular accuracy
4) Both need to make plays with their legs if they hope to ever move the ball. PW has more speed here whereas Tebow has more power.

[Skinzman]

Originally Posted by Lotus

I see PW and Tebow as basically the same level:

1) Neither can read an NFL defense
2) Neither can complete a pass for longer than 15 yards
3) Neither throws with particular accuracy
4) Both need to make plays with their legs if they hope to ever move the ball. PW has more speed here whereas Tebow has more power.

Im certainly not trying to endorse Tebow, but he throws a better deep ball than short ball. He just needs 5 seconds to do so since his wind up is long and slow and its rare that he can get enough time to do so. Even if the receiver is open, half the time he misses the read and takes off running. Tebow can complete two passes, the seam route and the deep ball. He is terrible on just about all the other throws.

[Lotus]

Originally Posted by Skinzman

Im certainly not trying to endorse Tebow, but he throws a better deep ball than short ball. He just needs 5 seconds to do so since his wind up is long and slow and its rare that he can get enough time to do so. Even if the receiver is open, half the time he misses the read and takes off running. Tebow can complete two passes, the seam route and the deep ball. He is terrible on just about all the other throws.

I agree with your assessment. But it still means that he has trouble completing the deep ball, hence in part his career 6.7 YPA.

Choosing Pat White vs. Tebow is like choosing whether you want Grossman or Beck to start. I'm glad that we never were in that position.