Colt Brennan vs Rookie class

[SmootSmack]

Someone's begging for a parrot.

[GTripp0012]

My head is sufficiently asploded. Got to go to a thread where people are realistic enough to not think of Colt Brennan as a future starter.

There's probably some merit to the thread here, but it's been ruined.

[Ruhskins]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

So...as per the thread title what about Colt vs. the rookie class? Personally I think there is room for both Colt and a rookie.

It appears that we've hit a time warp and we've been transported back to the beginning of the 2009 season when there was an actual debate about Campbell.

[CRedskinsRule]

Originally Posted by redskins202

I'm sorry so than why hasn't Jason Candle been re-sign yet my good sir?
Would you like for me to show you stats of when Campbell is out and in and how good Santana Moss produces more sir?

And your criticism is back in 08 when every one should have known Jason wasnt that impressive.

JC hasn't been re-signed because he hasn't proven himself a franchise QB. Everyone agrees on that.

He hasn't been released because he isn't the only reason we were 4-12. Most everyone understands that too.

What Shanahan does with him now will depend on what MS wants as a future qb. And only MS can answer that one, I am sure we will have a far better idea after this draft.

[CultBrennan59]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

Oh please. His argument is nothing that a "you're dumb" or a "that's stupid" can't sufficiently answer. Your work here mining for the acceptance of a noob who can barely type in sentences is so weak.

The reason the argument sucks is because it's based on not a single premise. It's based on the authoritative word of someone who has been here all of 15 minutes and might be 14 years old.

The single premise is that Jason Campbell sucks, end of story back to Brennan, which is what this thread is about.

[redskins202]

Originally Posted by CultBrennan59

Couldn't have said it any better my friend. People here just need a change of sceneary. They're still sold on Jason being our QB even though he's played 4 years for us and been here 5 years. I bet you as soon as we get a franchise caliber QB in the draft and he starts performing well people will be saying "Jason Who?" Until then we're still going to be hearing "Hey give Jason a shot," "He hasn't played behind a good OL yet," "Let him be in an offense for more than 2 years," its like people are so sold on this guy that they believe he's like the only QB out there or something, like we can't draft one or trade for one or whatever.

What I hate is there protecting a guy who.

1: Made us be a big part of an 4-12 in the easiest schedule ever. The 05 redskins probably would have gone 14-2 with this schedule.

2: Jason is turning 29 and right now is a free agent who either can be traded or sign off to another team but if at best would be here for one year. They are protecting a QB whos gonna be here for one year????.

3: How is Jason Candle our best option? he's no better than Marc Bulger or Chad Pennington. This guy couldn't even give us a 3rd-4th rounder in his supposed best year in 08. Jets where eyeing him what happend?. They saw the Videos and saw how bad he is. Shanahan see's the videos and knows now we need a QB.


me and you ...will be the best of friends lol.

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by CultBrennan59

The single premise is that Jason Campbell sucks, end of story back to Brennan, which is what this thread is about.

Which is exactly why you've killed the thread.

Colt Brennan's NFL prospects are dead. He's 26, and basically played his way to free agency last preseason. There's a new Sheriff in town, he'll get a workout, and that will be the end of him. Or so I predict.

[Ruhskins]

Originally Posted by CultBrennan59

The single premise is that Jason Campbell sucks, end of story back to Brennan, which is what this thread is about.

Well I guess you're glad of this because weren't you the one that early in the season wanted the Redskins to lose so we can have a top 5 pick? If memory serves me right, I used to call you a Cowboys fan.

[redskins202]

Originally Posted by Ruhskins

, what the hell are you talking about? You're just being a moron right now that's bringing up crap that was discussed all of last season.

So your arguing about Campbell being here for one year than?. I mean thats what obviously your saying...part of the reason was every one else but Campbell . I mean its not Campbell fault for a 4-12 record.

Yep. K i see what you mean.

[CultBrennan59]

Anyway Brennan deserves a shot just like how Campbell and Collins both got shots last year to be a starting QB, and by a shot I mean he gets to play with the starters and not 2nd/3rd Stringers.

[redskins202]

Originally Posted by Ruhskins

No one is sold on Jason Campbell, we're just sick of simple minded people that think a simple change of QB will make us into a Super Bowl contender right away. The only reason Campbell is being brought up, is because some people want us to take a franchise tackle and keep Campbell in the interim until either we can a.) develop a mid-round QB or b.) we can pick up a first-round QB in 2011.

K.............so lets just draft Bradford than. Campbell gonna be here for one year I guess or get traded. So no problems here guess we where mis-understood.

[SmootSmack]

Originally Posted by CRedskinsRule

JC hasn't been re-signed because he hasn't proven himself a franchise QB. Everyone agrees on that.

He hasn't been released because he isn't the only reason we were 4-12. Most everyone understands that too.

What Shanahan does with him now will depend on what MS wants as a future qb. And only MS can answer that one, I am sure we will have a far better idea after this draft.

You and me...we'll be great friends here

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by CultBrennan59

Anyway Brennan deserves a shot just like how Campbell and Collins both got shots last year to be a starting QB, and by a shot I mean he gets to play with the starters and not 2nd/3rd Stringers.

Brennan had his shot. Now, Andre Woodson, he didn't get any meaningful gametime here before we moved on. Brennan has been here two preseasons.

It was a 6th round pick that didnt pay off. Won't be the last.

[Ruhskins]

Originally Posted by redskins202

So your arguing about Campbell being here for one year than?. I mean thats what obviously your saying...part of the reason was every one else but Campbell . I mean its not Campbell fault for a 4-12 record.

Yep. K i see what you mean.

Yes, I'm arguing for Campbell to be here for just a year, so we can use our resources in our offensive line, since we have an aging left tackle that has a possibly career-ending injury, and a right tackle that has no business being a starter.

However, you insist on attacking Campbell as though someone is calling for him to get an extended contract and that his the franchise QB of the team. No one is arguing that, and you look a bit ridiculous bringing arguments that were debated to death here last fall. So just drop it.

[celts32]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

Joke based on a commercial Campbell did for Geico (I think) where they poked fun at him and called him Jason Candle

Okay...I missed that Ad.