Would Joe Gibbs Be Considered The Greatest Coach If He Won SB 18?

[CrustyRedskin]

He'll always be my favorite and thats all that matters to me. Walsh not too far behind.

[skinsnut]

For all you Gibbs 2.0 haters....
2 winning seasons in the last 11 years....both by Gibbs, one after the murder of the teams best player and a backup QB with 5 games to go and a losing record.

This is a man of incredible motivation...the talent on these teams was mediocre at best...

I remember folks saying picking up Shanny would automatically add "x" # of wins...that only works with Gibbs folks. Gibbs truly is and always will be the best Skins coach of all time....he could get milk from a stone.
Just think if he was coach this year...Haynesworth would probably be an all pro and the run game would be solid with Sellers and Cooley in on every play
We wouldn't have wussy zone blocking lightweight...Dockery would powerblock all day...with solid results..

Imagine Gibbs with Banks...he would be the #2 WR by now going deep and running reverses and taking quick screens....and no way in Hell the Defense would rank #32...the team would be far too embarrased to even walk by his door with that sort of effort.

My main point is this...Gibbs is a master motivator, thats what makes him one of a kind...hand the same team to someone else and it may collape...as it has done twice.

[MTK]

Gibbs was 6-10 his first year back, Shanny might be headed for the same mark funny enough.

[sportscurmudgeon]

To answer the question in the title of this thread: No he would not.

Joe Gibbs was one of the great NFL coaches and he is a class act as a human being. Would that every coach in the NFL - - and in all sports for that matter - - had the strength of character that he has to add to whatever skills those coaches might bring to their teams.

[SFREDSKIN]

Originally Posted by skinsnut

For all you Gibbs 2.0 haters....
2 winning seasons in the last 11 years....both by Gibbs, one after the murder of the teams best player and a backup QB with 5 games to go and a losing record.

This is a man of incredible motivation...the talent on these teams was mediocre at best...

I remember folks saying picking up Shanny would automatically add "x" # of wins...that only works with Gibbs folks. Gibbs truly is and always will be the best Skins coach of all time....he could get milk from a stone.
Just think if he was coach this year...Haynesworth would probably be an all pro and the run game would be solid with Sellers and Cooley in on every play
We wouldn't have wussy zone blocking lightweight...Dockery would powerblock all day...with solid results..

Imagine Gibbs with Banks...he would be the #2 WR by now going deep and running reverses and taking quick screens....and no way in Hell the Defense would rank #32...the team would be far too embarrased to even walk by his door with that sort of effort.

My main point is this...Gibbs is a master motivator, thats what makes him one of a kind...hand the same team to someone else and it may collape...as it has done twice.

Couldn't agree more, you get it.

[skinsguy]

Originally Posted by skinsnut

For all you Gibbs 2.0 haters....
2 winning seasons in the last 11 years....both by Gibbs, one after the murder of the teams best player and a backup QB with 5 games to go and a losing record.

This is a man of incredible motivation...the talent on these teams was mediocre at best...

I remember folks saying picking up Shanny would automatically add "x" # of wins...that only works with Gibbs folks. Gibbs truly is and always will be the best Skins coach of all time....he could get milk from a stone.
Just think if he was coach this year...Haynesworth would probably be an all pro and the run game would be solid with Sellers and Cooley in on every play
We wouldn't have wussy zone blocking lightweight...Dockery would powerblock all day...with solid results..

Imagine Gibbs with Banks...he would be the #2 WR by now going deep and running reverses and taking quick screens....and no way in Hell the Defense would rank #32...the team would be far too embarrased to even walk by his door with that sort of effort.

My main point is this...Gibbs is a master motivator, thats what makes him one of a kind...hand the same team to someone else and it may collape...as it has done twice.

Amen!