Would You Play Campbell vs Ravens?

[hooskins]

The Ravens have too good of a D to put Campbell against. Personally I would be happy with putting him and the rest of the starters in for one drive, and rest everyone.

I am sick of injuries.

[sandman89]

start for 1-3 series at least

[chrisl4064]

i hate the pre season, because of this garbage. meaningless injuries.... this is one sport where its just not needed.

that being said, sit campbell. if hes in a situation where he NEEDS a few more reps than maybe he isnt as ready as we all thought. the kid should be good to start the season.

[skinsfan_nn]

If JC is ready to go, why would you not give him work? Yes, if he's ready to go of course.

[Beemnseven]

This is a tough one, but I reluctantly vote yes. Make this his shortest appearance though.

This would be a good time for him to work on quick, timing pattern throws. Get the ball out of his hands as quickly as possible -- avoid deep dropbacks at all costs. The other problem is his desire to make a play by scrambling if nobody's open. My heart will probably explode through my chest when he starts running with the ball.

[12thMan]

I heard JC on the radio this morning, he said the knee was still a little stiff, and that he can jog, but can't run.

[MTK]

Yeah sounds like he's not going to play this week, I'm fine with that if he's still sore.

[Skinny Tee]

Campbell has already played against the Ravens during the scrimmage. He doesn't need another outing against them. Sit him out just in case Terrell Suggs's dojomaster tells him to "sweep the leg".

Let Collins start and play extensively with the first team, since we were almost relegated to that fate anyway.

[BDBohnzie]

I'd rather see Campbell rest and be 100% than risk another injury at less than. If he's 100%, by all means. However, I don't see him practicing much this week.

I'd like to see Collins and Brunell alternate with the 1st team. Watching Brunell the last 2 weeks has been mind-numbing...and while Collins isn't much better, he's having a better preseason.

[Sheriff Gonna Getcha]

No thanks. I know it is important for the starting QB to gain experience through the preseason, but I would prefer to see Jason keep his head for the regular season. The Ravens will eat Heyer and Pucillo alive and, if we're allowing 3 sacks a game to the Titans and Steelers, I don't want to know what they'll do to a wounded JC. I say rest him.

[Monkeydad]

Originally Posted by Skinny Tee

Campbell has already played against the Ravens during the scrimmage. He doesn't need another outing against them. Sit him out just in case Terrell Suggs's dojomaster tells him to "sweep the leg".

Let Collins start and play extensively with the first team, since we were almost relegated to that fate anyway.

That scrimmage was barely anything resembling a real game situation. It was pretty much a practice.

[2BIG2BSKINNY]

I agree with the 12 Man

You have more to gain by sitting JC and Finding out if Collins can handle the No. 2 job...and then we can also see the young guns Bramblet and Palmer in limited action.

[SouperMeister]

The third preseason game is usually the one that most resembles live conditions of the regular season. Given that the opponent is Baltimore, I don't want any part of exposing Campbell to Baltimore's fierce pass rush, especially with a backup O-lineman protecting his blind side.

[SmootSmack]

For what it's worth, I've heard that the Skins intend to name Palmer the #3 QB. Brunell and Collins are basically being showcased this preseason for one of them to get traded in the next couple of weeks.

Let me be clear though, the Redskins are not actively shopping either one. Other teams have inquired and the Skins will only trade them if they find the right deal. If they don't then both likely stay and Palmer heads to the PS.

[70Chip]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

For what it's worth, I've heard that the Skins intend to name Palmer the #3 QB. Brunell and Collins are basically being showcased this preseason for one of them to get traded in the next couple of weeks.

Let me be clear though, the Redskins are not actively shopping either one. Other teams have inquired and the Skins will only trade them if they find the right deal. If they don't then both likely stay and Palmer heads to the PS.

What are the cap ramifications of a Brunell or Collins trade? BTW, I think we're talking about a Brunell trade here. Collins would be completely useless in a different system. He's pretty useless in this one.