Week 3 TQBR Rankings

[CRedskinsRule]

Originally Posted by 30gut

Romo
Rex
Eli
Vick

nope

StatLine Check:
PC -- PA -- YD -- % -- YPC -- TD -- LONG -- INT FUM.RATING
Vick
79 129..........1,021.....61.2.....7.92.....6........ ..61..........3.....1.....91.9
Rex
83 143............989......58.0.....6.92.....6....... ...40..........5.....2.....78.7
Romo
99 152..........1,273.....65.1.....8.38.....7........ ..77..........5.....3.....92.9
Eli:
80 125..........1,066.....64.0.....8.53.....8....... 74..........2.....2.....105.6
...

[CRedskinsRule]

Originally Posted by Giantone

......and which one has a super bowl ring?

and this matters for this season, why?

[Ruhskins]

Originally Posted by Giantone

......and which one has a super bowl ring?

I didn't know SB rings were part of the TBQR rankings. Maybe Rex can get a half a point for playing in a SB?

[Lotus]

Originally Posted by Giantone

......and which one has a super bowl ring?

David Tyree has the same Super Bowl ring but certainly you would not name him as a top receiver this year, would you?

[Giantone]

Originally Posted by Lotus

David Tyree has the same Super Bowl ring but certainly you would not name him as a top receiver this year, would you?

YOU were talking about TOP QB's this year correct?

[Ruhskins]

Originally Posted by Giantone

YOU were talking about TOP QB's this year correct?

Yep and we are talking about top QBs this year based on their statistics this year and not past glory.

[Giantone]

Originally Posted by CRedskinsRule

and this matters for this season, why?

It matters anytime people bring out useless stats to prove a point and forget the most important one...does he(the QB) win.

[Giantone]

Originally Posted by Ruhskins

I didn't know SB rings were part of the TBQR rankings. Maybe Rex can get a half a point for playing in a SB?

.....no.


look Vick was super man....last year,Romo.....great stats till he hits the playoffs,Rex.....well. Eli when he's on he is one of the best but....when he's bad........it's ugly. TBQR means ....nothing,look you guys think Rex is king ...why, becuase you are WINNING and that is the only stat that matters.

[hooskins]

Originally Posted by Giantone

.....no.


look Vick was super man....last year,Romo.....great stats till he hits the playoffs,Rex.....well. Eli when he's on he is one of the best but....when he's bad........it's ugly. TBQR means ....nothing,look you guys think Rex is king ...why, becuase you are WINNING and that is the only stat that matters.

TQBR is one of the better metrics that factors wins, fourth quarter comebacks and pivotal plays. This isn't your father's QB Rating, therefore it most definitely matters in this discussion.

[Lotus]

Originally Posted by Giantone

.....no.


look Vick was super man....last year,Romo.....great stats till he hits the playoffs,Rex.....well. Eli when he's on he is one of the best but....when he's bad........it's ugly. TBQR means ....nothing,look you guys think Rex is king ...why, becuase you are WINNING and that is the only stat that matters.

Who thinks that? I don't know anyone who thinks that.

[That Guy]

G-one, you should probably read this forum, or at least two posts before making sweeping generalizations that aren't true... I mean, you don't even need to go outside this thread to see that everyone here thinks rex is either average or replaceable (did you notice the start john beck thread?)

come on, man.

[mooby]

Originally Posted by Giantone

.....no.


look Vick was super man....last year,Romo.....great stats till he hits the playoffs,Rex.....well. Eli when he's on he is one of the best but....when he's bad........it's ugly. TBQR means ....nothing,look you guys think Rex is king ...why, becuase you are WINNING and that is the only stat that matters.

Whoa whoa whoa, slow your role there. I'm just gonna assume you saw Jonny5dicky's posts way back in preseason because I'm pretty confident most of this board doesn't think either Beck or Grossman are the future here. Grossman's just an average qb.

[SirClintonPortis]

I will say this, the weekly TQBR's of (Un)Sexy Rexy has been pretty good at showing how Rex has been playing. An amazing first game, a so-so second game, a stinker, and one slightly better than the stinker. The standard deviation for his tqbr must be insanely large...

It's better than what the qbr would say: amazing first game, so-so second game, so-so third game, complete ass the fourth game.

[Giantone]

Originally Posted by SirClintonPortis

I will say this, the weekly TQBR's of (Un)Sexy Rexy has been pretty good at showing how Rex has been playing. An amazing first game, a so-so second game, a stinker, and one slightly better than the stinker. The standard deviation for his tqbr must be insanely large...

It's better than what the qbr would say: amazing first game, so-so second game, so-so third game, complete ass the fourth game.

But this is what I mean,reminds me of the 2000 Ravens with Dilfer.So what if Rex is so-so .....your words not mine....he's winning, becuase at the end of the day there is only one stat that matters did you win the game and if it 's yes then he's a good QB.Pretty sure Kelly or Marino would give up their stats for a ring.

[Giantone]

Originally Posted by hooskins

TQBR is one of the better metrics that factors wins, fourth quarter comebacks and pivotal plays. This isn't your father's QB Rating, therefore it most definitely matters in this discussion.

Why does a 4th quarter comeback mean a great QB,....example Giants and eagles last year.....the D and special teams lost that game .....Vick didn't win it all by himself.