There's No Quarterback Controversy

[charlielyons]

the same people who dont want campbell benched are also the same ones who wanted greg williams as HC. change is a good thing sometimes

[A10sROCK]

JC QB rating is going down - just like it did last year before he was hurt.

I don't think he should be benched. We need to give him a full season to be the starting QB. This season.

However, giving him all next season also, "to develop" is crazy. Five years to prove himself? No team uses 5 seasons to try a QB.

Either he proves he can be the long-term QB, or by next year there will be a veteran WCO QB (to replace Colllins), and Colt will be here also to challenge him.

Zorn is not going to bet his Head Coaching job on Campbell unless he has the goods.

[SmootSmack]

Originally Posted by charlielyons

the same people who dont want campbell benched are also the same ones who wanted greg williams as HC. change is a good thing sometimes

Well this is one poster who didn't want Williams as HC, and doesn't want Campbell benched.

[Sheriff Gonna Getcha]

Originally Posted by charlielyons

the same people who dont want campbell benched are also the same ones who wanted greg williams as HC. change is a good thing sometimes

Or, it can be a horrible, horrible thing.

[Sheriff Gonna Getcha]

Originally Posted by charlielyons

what has campbell done so great?

What has Colt done that is so great? He had two good games and two really bad games against 3rd stringers in the preseason. If you bench Campbell, you might as well cut him. Are you prepared to throw Campbell to the scrap heap for a guy who has never taken a single snap in an NFL game? If you are, you've got a lot of blind faith.

[A10sROCK]

This was Jason's season. All of it. If the offense has a good year the QB gets the glory. If it isn't, then you get the blame.

If Zorn did start Colt in the last games then it's a HUGE sign to me that he doesn't believe Jason can carry this team. He won't do that.

Zorn will let Jason finish the season and think things over in the quiet of the off-season.

[charlielyons]

Originally Posted by Sheriff Gonna Getcha

What has Colt done that is so great? He had two good games and two really bad games against 3rd stringers in the preseason. If you bench Campbell, you might as well cut him. Are you prepared to throw Campbell to the scrap heap for a guy who has never taken a single snap in an NFL game? If you are, you've got a lot of blind faith.

colt hasnt done anything great. but if we are out of the playoff hunt...hes worth a look.

[hooskins]

Originally Posted by charlielyons

the same people who dont want campbell benched are also the same ones who wanted greg williams as HC. change is a good thing sometimes

That's definitely not true.

[53Fan]

[quote=charlielyons;506681]the same people who dont want campbell benched are also the same ones who wanted greg williams as HC. change is a good thing sometimes[/quote]

That's ........... Just saw on Comcast JC is the 3rd most sacked QB in the NFL.

[charlielyons]

the offensive line has big problems, but JC does not read the defensive quickly and his release is very slow.

[MTK]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

Well this is one poster who didn't want Williams as HC, and doesn't want Campbell benched.

same here

[JLW428]

Charlie - This is exactly why players try to tune out the fans voice, I really don't understand why you wan't to see colt so much. Coaches see him in practice along side JC and TC. Believe me, they know more about these QBs than you do - or for that matter pretty much any of us do. Even if we go out of the playoff race, I HIGHLY doubt that we will see any of Colt in a game situation unless something truely catastrophic happens. Just not going to happen bud - let it go.

[schndr_tdd]

Colt is a damn good QB who brings energy to the offense.He is a future pro-bowler,remember that i said this a few years from now...I just hope its not on another team!!!!!

[schndr_tdd]

Campbell is slow in his reads and hesitant in his decisions.Id rather have a gun-slinger someone who takes chances downfield, brings energy,and excitement..THE OFFENSE IS STAGNANT WITHOUT PORTIS!!!!!!

[53Fan]

JC needs as much time in this offense as he can get... to get better. Benching him would retard that growth just as some of these posts have retarded this thread.