Switch to 3-4 Defense a Failure

[Bishop Hammer]

Originally Posted by CrazyCanuck

You hit the nail on the head. While 4-3 vs. 3-4 may be a worthy debate, I think it's moot in this case.

No way Shanny goes back now, not after 3 years. The only way I could see it would be with a new DC. Then Shanny could say "I still prefer the 3-4 but for the good of the team I have decided to defer to our new DC."

Shanny won't do that because he won't admit he made a mistake. Mikey also won't get a strong DC. Even if Haslett is gone his replacement won't fare much better. MS doesn't have an eye for defensive talent and no inkling how to construct a defense. Very rarely has he had a dominant D. Its a shame because when he's had one his teams have done well. I don't see that happening with our beloved Skins.