Rattay tears groin

[BrudLee]

Originally Posted by SKINSnCANES

Yea I agree, Dorsey would have been a much better pick. Dorsey will succeed because all he knows how to do is win. People say his arm isnt strong enough, well its not as strong as most QBs, but if you know that and make the smart throws it doesnt matter. GO CANES

There are a litany of guys who won at the college level that couldn't play in the NFL. Hamdan may have been a foolish pick (since he likely would have been available as a free agent after the draft), but Dorsey's relatively weak arm puts him on the same page as the dozens of QB's with winning records whose physical skills don't match up to the pro game.

As the success of other players from storied programs (like Miami, in this case) shows us, the QB gets too much credit for victories. Remember the players Dorsey had around him - Portis, Shockey, et al. With players like that, I could succeed on the 1-A level.