Coach Changes: Firings/Hirings

[Giantone]

Originally Posted by CRedskinsRule

I didn't say that. My post's implication was that none of the new HC's appear to be world beaters.

As for our division:
Garrett is 40-40 over 5 years, and isn't likely to be a HOF'er in any sense of the word.

Pederson's last head coaching job (2005-2008) was the Calvary Baptist Academy. I'm thinking that the competition at the NFL level is just a little more difficult.

McAdoo has never been a head coach at ANY level. I guess that's a good thing right?


Do I think we will roll, no, but I do think we have a solid GM for the first time in Snyder's ownership, a HC who has won championships at a semi pro level, and shown progression in the NFL, and have a young promising qb.

Garrett is banking on Romo,to me a dumb bet.

Pederson's been with Andy Reid a hell of a long time and anyone is better the Chip Kelly.Philly's D was not half bad.

McAdoo you're 100% right about but Bill Parcells was a head coach at the Air Force Academy one season pretty sure that didn't help for the NFL.Can he do as well only if Reese does his job well.All so he does have a ring so that can't hurt.

Gruden is still a question.(I like him) but was this a one time thing or can he do it all the time?These are not shots but legitimate questions about all the coaches in the NFC East.

[CRedskinsRule]

Originally Posted by Giantone

Garrett is banking on Romo,to me a dumb bet.

Pederson's been with Andy Reid a hell of a long time and anyone is better the Chip Kelly.Philly's D was not half bad.

McAdoo you're 100% right about but Bill Parcells was a head coach at the Air Force Academy one season pretty sure that didn't help for the NFL.Can he do as well only if Reese does his job well.All so he does have a ring so that can't hurt.

Gruden is still a question.(I like him) but was this a one time thing or can he do it all the time?These are not shots but legitimate questions about all the coaches in the NFC East.

Which was my point about the hires. I'm glad that neither team that was looking for a HC brought in someone who is clearly head and shoulders above an NFL average HC. Could McAdoo/Pederson be the next big thing sure, but if so, there's not a lick of track record to show it.