Whats Fair When it Comes to Taxes?

[mlmpetert]

Originally Posted by saden1

Who told you life is fair? If it was fair we would all be well off, there wouldn't be children that go to sleep hungry at night or homeless veterans, or fund managers who pay 15% CGT on the hard earned money of others.

Get over your pursuit of perfection and fairness and start seeking sensibility and practicality. It doesn't seem fair to me to have the local grocery bagger pay $4 for a loaf of bread and 15% on their income tax and for the CEO of the grocery store to also pays $4 for a loaf of bread and 15% on their income tax. On the surface it looks pretty fair but while the CEO wipes his ass with $100 bills and is unable to notice a measly $4 the grocery store clerk will.

The cost of rent/mortgage and consumable goods are high and unless you want to live like a caveman someone making 30k can barely survive in this country. Bottom line is the clerk will consume most of his income on all the things one need to live a decent life while the CEO can't spend enough to on his neighborhood for eternity. As such they shouldn't be treated the same in matter of taxation.

Some will say, well, why should the CEO have to subsidize other people...to these people I say who is subsidizing the CEO and why shouldn't they pay more considering they benefit the most?

In school I was always taught that the reason people come to America is for opportunity. That America guarantees the pursuit of happiness for everyone but not a guarantee that everyone will be happy.

We are all born into different circumstances but just like you said life isn’t fair. Just like its not fair that some people are harder workers then others, smarter, better looking, smooth talking, better athletically, more innovative or...... just good ole rich. That’s just the way it is, some people are dealt better cards then others. Im not rich and I don’t come from a rich family, but I don’t think rich people should be punished just like I don’t think a hard worker, athlete or model should be punished because of their lack of misfortune.

I think people who earn more money should pay more taxes because like you said they are benefiting the most. That’s why I think a percentage is fair, as you earn more you pay more. I also think people at the bottom of the economic scale should be given more opportunity, kind of like they are now but through a more controlled process. So instead of giving someone a huge tax refund (relative to their income) at the end of the year to do what they like with, I think it would be more beneficial to provide them with tools through social programs that present individuals with opportunities to climb the economic latter if that what they choose to do. This would replace tax refunds and be in addition to the subsidies like housing vouchers and food stamps that many of us are already receiving. So more oppertunity for poorer people but its up to you to take advantage of it. Things will never be fair for everyone but i think treating everyone equally is start.