Brett Favre Decision

[freddyg12]

lot of good points in this thread. Sure hope brunell doesn't try this next year!
I'll give farve credit for his great years & his overall class, but he needs to step up & realize that the packers shouldn't make free agent decisisons based on him coming back cause they're gonna have to rebuild with or without him.
Fact is, for at least the last 3 years he's been as much a problem for the team w/his play as he has been a plus. How does a vet qb get away w/so many ill advised into coverage passes, many of which get picked off? If you watch the highlights of that famous monday night game against oak. he threw a few jump balls that driver & walker came down with. Remember the game against us in 04? He lit it up in the 1st half, but then we picked off 3 from him in the 2nd & if not for a bogus illegal motion call that negated a td by portis, we could've won that one. The packers deserve credit for trying to gently ease out a legend, but they'd be better off to get rodgers in the mix asap.

[Monkeydad]

Originally Posted by Sociofan

Dude, pulling the racial card is just ridiculous.

I agree...look how the media acted when Rush Limbaugh had a back surgery go bad and he got some extra painkillers. It's not a black or white issue, the media just picks and chooses their people to become outraged at.

I wouldn't condemn anyone who legitimately has a lot of pain and overdoes painkillers, it's VERY easy to do and takes a lot of self control to prevent. I know that from experience.

Moss and pot vs. Favre and pills from a doctor? You've got to be kidding, trying to compare the two. One is ILLEGAL, the other is just a bad decision.

I'm sure Randy's past record with his behavior around police didn't help his case either.

Favre has been through a lot and I applaud him personally for making it through such tough issues, but as a player...I think he's done. He's no longer the QB he used to be and in many times he hurts his team more than he helps them now. I know he didn't have a supporting cast last year, but dropped passes didn't hurt him, his decision-making and accuracy did. He just doesn't have it any more. If he's too competitive to go out on a disaster season like last year, he needs to let his team know he's coming back. If he does play this year and can't win with his WRs and RBs back from injury, he needs to start getting Rogers ready to play. He's rotting in his headset.

The press conference to announce that he's still thinking was beyond stupid.

[Beemnseven]

Originally Posted by Buster

... look how the media acted when Rush Limbaugh had a back surgery go bad and he got some extra painkillers. It's not a black or white issue, the media just picks and chooses their people to become outraged at.

I wouldn't condemn anyone who legitimately has a lot of pain and overdoes painkillers, it's VERY easy to do and takes a lot of self control to prevent. I know that from experience.

Moss and pot vs. Favre and pills from a doctor? You've got to be kidding, trying to compare the two. One is ILLEGAL, the other is just a bad decision.

How the media "acted" after learning that Rush Limbaugh was addicted to Oxycontin was to report it, along with the fact that he could have faced criminal charges for a ridiculous statute called 'doctor shopping' under Florida law. Any time someone famous happens to become involved in these circumstances, especially one that has railed against drug use and claimed that those who abuse such illegal drugs should be "locked up" -- it should be as evident as the sky is blue that the media is going to mention it.

And don't confuse the term 'illegal' when one drug is marijuana and the other is Oxycontin -- illicit prescription drug use, and the covert means by which one attempts to obtain it without a doctor's approval is just as illegal (and as absurd, in my opinion).

Aside from the criminal penalties that may be different depending on what drug is used, THERE IS NO DIFFERENCE between a marijuana, cocaine, or herion addict and one who abuses the "nicer" drugs like codiene or Oxycontin. The fact is, both sets of individuals took the drugs to address their needs. One to relieve pain from back surgery, one to achieve inebriation and to fight the pain of withdrawal.

The bottom line is that all laws concerning drugs of every kind should be completely and totally repealled.

[SUNRA]

I have read every thread today concerning Brett Favre and I can count approximately 3 threads that get right down to the nitty gritty of the subject.
The behavior that Brett Favre has exhibited in the the last 2 months towards his teammates and fans is coming from one who is opportunistic, self-absorbed, insecure and a god damn hypocrite. This self righteous moron had the unmitigated audacity to call Javon Walker out in the press last year about his absence in training camp, and turns right around and makes a statement, " Whata' they going to do, cut me. " That's right. That's what the hypocrite said.

Brett Favre is a major contributor to what's wrong with the NFL because when he's wrong, which is most of the time, he gets a pass because of his statisical accomplishments and personal tragedies. So god damn what. He shits and pisses like the rest of us and should have been scorched in the media. Most of what the coverage has been is vanilla, pussy footing bullshit instead of a critical analysis of last season which clearly showed he was the worst QB in the league. When Mark Brunell stunk up the place in 2004 , everybody had an opinion on the subject. But for some reason, only Micheal Irvin had the balls to call Favre out on Prime Time. No player is above his team, right? What about when it's a good ole' boy whom everybody seems to drool over and can't seem to do any wrong even if he insults the very organization that he achieved his greatness? Man, to hell with Brett Favre. I can name 100 people in the NFL who have had worst tragedies than him.

[SmootSmack]

I thought he was joking around when he said "What are they going to do? Cut me"

Anyhow, it's so rare to find an athlete who knows when to quit. If you're at the top of your game you think "why can't I do this another year or more?" and if you slip you think "why can't I bounce back?"

Some of the past century's greatest athletes (such as Ruth, Mays, Unitas, Emmitt) finished with disappointingly uncharacteristic results, sometimes embarrasingly so. But in the long run, I don't think it does any damage to their legacy.

I think Favre will play one more season and it will be his "farewell tour" I think he wants to play his last game knowing its his last game. So the Aaron Rodgers era will begin in 2007, IMO.

[saden1]

I'd like to give a shout-out to my man Berry Sanders for doing what he did on and off the field and for retiring with his legendary status still in perfect condition.

[saden1]

Originally Posted by SUNRA

I have read every thread today concerning Brett Favre and I can count approximately 3 threads that get right down to the nitty gritty of the subject.
The behavior that Brett Favre has exhibited in the the last 2 months towards his teammates and fans is coming from one who is opportunistic, self-absorbed, insecure and a god damn hypocrite. This self righteous moron had the unmitigated audacity to call Javon Walker out in the press last year about his absence in training camp, and turns right around and makes a statement, " Whata' they going to do, cut me. " That's right. That's what the hypocrite said.

Brett Favre is a major contributor to what's wrong with the NFL because when he's wrong, which is most of the time, he gets a pass because of his statisical accomplishments and personal tragedies. So god damn what. He shits and pisses like the rest of us and should have been scorched in the media. Most of what the coverage has been is vanilla, pussy footing bullshit instead of a critical analysis of last season which clearly showed he was the worst QB in the league. When Mark Brunell stunk up the place in 2004 , everybody had an opinion on the subject. But for some reason, only Micheal Irvin had the balls to call Favre out on Prime Time. No player is above his team, right? What about when it's a good ole' boy whom everybody seems to drool over and can't seem to do any wrong even if he insults the very organization that he achieved his greatness? Man, to hell with Brett Favre. I can name 100 people in the NFL who have had worst tragedies than him.

Preach on bra'h, preach on! Favre was definitely a punk bitch for opening his mouth on Walker's monetary dispute last year and I called him on that.

And only fools think there is a difference between illegal and legal drugs besides one being approved by the government for the sake of drug companies. The whole thing reminds me of person that drinks enough alcohol to get a buzz every day yet still maintains they don't have a drinking problem. Speaking of alcohol, that's one hell of a legal drug!

[SmootSmack]

Originally Posted by saden1

I'd like to give a show out to my man Berry Sanders for doing what he did on and off the field and for retiring with his legendary status still in perfect condition.

Yup. Although some say he retired too early. I do, but only for selfish reasons. Loved watching him play.

[jrocx69]

Originally Posted by SkinsLove24/7

Who else thinks this is the most annoying story this offseason and even over the past few offseasons. I mean make up your mind already. He is one of the great ones to play quarterback but this is ridiculous. He calls a press conference for today (Saturday) and announces that he still has not made up his mind. The T.O. situation was annoying as well but at least things changed and there was always different things happeneing. Brett needs to make up his mind so he and the Packers can move on while we can stop hearing about it.

if its annoying then dont read it, or turn the channel, the guy is stuck between playing for the team he loves and hanging it up b/c the front office decided to take away his coach, guards, and not pay javon, oh yeah, and not get shit back for all that has left the team. he has earned the right to be a little selfish.

[SUNRA]

New revelation. Because of Mr. Favre's strong ethical stance on the subject of Green Bay persuing a big name player to motivate his decision. Well, guess who Green Bay is interested in? Lavar Arrington. He's meeting the organization today 4/11. Man, this is hilarious. Green Bay please sign Lavar, please.

[MTK]

It's funny, but not surprising how quickly we turn on our stars.

Favre has had a Hall of Fame career, he's battled adversity, and he's generally been a pretty classy and standup guy.

Now he's faced with a difficult decision and people are jumping all over him. Could he be handling it better? Sure. Has he made some mistakes during his career? Of course... who hasn't?

But this witch hunt some people seem to be on is just really sickening. The race card is being played in some circles, people are bringing up his past problems that he's dealt with and already defeated... what's the point??

[Sociofan]

Originally Posted by Mattyk72

It's funny, but not surprising how quickly we turn on our stars.

Favre has had a Hall of Fame career, he's battled adversity, and he's generally been a pretty classy and standup guy.

Now he's faced with a difficult decision and people are jumping all over him. Could he be handling it better? Sure. Has he made some mistakes during his career? Of course... who hasn't?

But this witch hunt some people seem to be on is just really sickening. The race card is being played in some circles, people are bringing up his past problems that he's dealt with and already defeated... what's the point??

Thank you Matty.

It is interesting how much more personal football decisions have become with a combination of increased media access and the internet. Brett might be having a hard time deciding whether or not to hang them up, but does anyone really want to see him in another uniform? Not me. I remember when a brash quarterback named Joe Namath had his knees go out, but rather than hang them up, he went to the L.A. Rams and tried playing a couple more seasons. It was terrible to watch. Worse than a train wreck. And people in New York just could not fathom Joe playing for another team. But despite his drinking and partying problem (oh, everyone knew about it then; the Suzy Kolber incident was just sort of the last straw), no one bashed Joe. So why does this stuff all get brought out for Brett Favre when all he's trying to do is figure out whether or not he's going to get one more legitimate shot at the playoffs? It's because all this stuff is unfiltered 24/7. Because of what Favre has done ON the field, he deserves the time to evaluate his future. There are a thousand players who have done/said or still do/say stupid things off the field. Don't single out Favre unless we apply the same scrutiny to every other player.

Late edit: Donovan McNabb has been saying the same things about the Eagles' failure to sign impact free agents when they have plenty of money beneath the cap. He has called out players for not showing up to camp. Is he up for the same level of bashing? Or will we see it for what it is? A very competitive QB calling out his teammates as their leader (a la Favre).

[12thMan]

I don't think anyone's singling out Farve, per se. And no one, at least I'm speaking for myself, is suggesting that he hasn't had a storied career. Because he has!

It's just human nature and perhaps cultural to examine people, both the good and the bad, that we hold in high regard. And we tend to make judgements accordingly. If this was, let's say......Joe Blow QB, we wouldn't give a rat's ass if he stayed, left or held a thousand press conferences. Because Brette has endeared so many people to himself over the years, he's going to take some heat, people are going to take some shots. It just comes with the territory, unfortunately.

I think in some weird sorta way, all of this back and forth, and the critism thrown his way legitimatizes the fact that he is an NFL great.

[Beemnseven]

Originally Posted by Mattyk72

It's funny, but not surprising how quickly we turn on our stars.

Favre has had a Hall of Fame career, he's battled adversity, and he's generally been a pretty classy and standup guy.

Now he's faced with a difficult decision and people are jumping all over him. Could he be handling it better? Sure. Has he made some mistakes during his career? Of course... who hasn't?

But this witch hunt some people seem to be on is just really sickening. The race card is being played in some circles, people are bringing up his past problems that he's dealt with and already defeated... what's the point??

I haven't turned on Brett Fav-rey. I've disliked him for quite awhile now. People may ask why, but to me, I tend to go against popular opinion -- when everyone drools over a particular star, whether it's football, movies, whatever -- I'm just not fond of media darlings, period.

Originally Posted by Sociofan

Thank you Matty.

It is interesting how much more personal football decisions have become with a combination of increased media access and the internet. Brett might be having a hard time deciding whether or not to hang them up, but does anyone really want to see him in another uniform? Not me. I remember when a brash quarterback named Joe Namath had his knees go out, but rather than hang them up, he went to the L.A. Rams and tried playing a couple more seasons. It was terrible to watch. Worse than a train wreck. And people in New York just could not fathom Joe playing for another team. But despite his drinking and partying problem (oh, everyone knew about it then; the Suzy Kolber incident was just sort of the last straw), no one bashed Joe. So why does this stuff all get brought out for Brett Favre when all he's trying to do is figure out whether or not he's going to get one more legitimate shot at the playoffs? It's because all this stuff is unfiltered 24/7. Because of what Favre has done ON the field, he deserves the time to evaluate his future. There are a thousand players who have done/said or still do/say stupid things off the field. Don't single out Favre unless we apply the same scrutiny to every other player.

Late edit: Donovan McNabb has been saying the same things about the Eagles' failure to sign impact free agents when they have plenty of money beneath the cap. He has called out players for not showing up to camp. Is he up for the same level of bashing? Or will we see it for what it is? A very competitive QB calling out his teammates as their leader (a la Favre).
04-11-2006 07:44 AM

No one's singling out Brett Fav-rey. He happens to be in the limelight regarding this question and the press loves to shine the spotlight on their media darling, especially when he's contemplating retirement. The problem I have, as many others do, is the way he's basing his decision: if the team is good, I'll come back. Football is the ultimate 'team' sport. Brett Farve was the main reason the Packers were bad last year, and have been for the past few seasons. He's a part of their failure as much as anyone else. For him to hold his fans and his team hostage and make demands the way he is, is self-serving in an environment that is supposed to be completely contrary to that notion. He's the spoiled brat that whines and pouts and threatens everyone that he's going home if things aren't done to his liking.

Sorry, but I've got little sympathy for such figures. Donovan McNabb can complain all he wants about his team not addressing it's needs in order to be competitive. But the difference is that he's not running home crying to mommy threatening that he doesn't want to play anymore if everything doesn't go his way.

Bottom line -- Brett Farve needs to grow up. If these statements are indicative of those that Farve is complaing about, and I've upset the jock-sniffers that love to follow him, then so be it. They can run home and cry to mommy too.

[MTK]

LOL blaming Favre for the team's massive injury problems and the front office's general failings in keeping the team competitive is pretty ridiculous.

Brett Farve was the main reason the Packers were bad last year, and have been for the past few seasons.

Really? Do you realize that last year was the only losing season the Packers have had under Favre. The only one.

Prior to last year the Packers W-L record looked like this under Favre.

2004: 10-6
2003: 10-6
2002: 12-4
2001: 12-4
2000: 9-7
1999: 8-8
1998: 11-5
1997: 13-3
1996: 13-3
1995: 11-5
1994: 9-7
1993: 9-7
1992: 9-7

If you take an objective look at the guy's career, last year sticks out like a fluke more than anything else. Injuries just decimated the team, and by the end of the year all they had was Favre, and his INTs climbed as he desperately tried to put the entire offense on his shoulders.

His career speaks for itself, and if anyone deserves some extra time to make a decision to retire, it's Favre.