Midseason (+1 game) Player Evaluation

[Paintrain]

I meant to do this post last week but didn't have time and coming off of Shanny's declaration that he is going into player evaluation mode, I figured we might as well give him some help. Without going player by player on the roster and discussing the obvious (RGIII & Hall for example) just some positives and negatives on both sides of the ball.

Surprises:
Morris-Well outperformed his draft slot. We seem to have solved the RB position for a couple of years.
The interior of the OL-They have performed really well after being a relatively major concern coming into the season. We rarely see pressure up the middle on passing plays, Chester and Liectenstiger seem to be getting to the second level in the running game and Montgomery has improved his shotgun snaps and blocking.
Morgan-He's been our best WR overall and despite his brain fart in the St. Louis game has proven to be a solid free agent pickup. He was a bit of an afterthought behind Garcon but as a #2 WR, he has solidified that spot.
Riley-In his first full year as a starter, while he hasn't made too many impact plays, his overall play has been solid. He plays fast and doesn't seem to repeat mistakes. He's probably never going to be a Pro Bowl LB but can be a solid starter for years.

Honorable mention: Paulson, LoAx, D. Young, Forbath

Disappointments
The DL as a whole-Bowen is the only one who stands out as a positive for me. Cofield was supposed to make a jump this year in his effectiveness but is showing to be a miscast NT. Jenkins either isn't fully recovered or isn't developing because he is just a guy out there, nothing special and not what you are counting on from a 2nd round pick. The guys aren't doing squat either as far as a pass rush is concerned as a unit. Decent against the run but we need more than that.
Kerrigan-I'll give him somewhat of a pass since he's got no threat opposite him to draw the OL attention, but too many times he has been stopped one on one by a RT with no help. We're not talking about superstar tackles either, its been guys he should be able to beat. Again, the lack of development is a concern. He is someone who we needed to step up and he has stepped back instead.
Fletcher-Sorry, but his time as a top level MLB is probably done. Just a couple glaring examples in the past 3 weeks: the 3rd and 10 vs. the Giants, he is one on one with Ahmad Bradshaw and got shook badly. The first carry of the game vs. the Giants when Bradshaw trucked him and put him on his back. Dwyer running through him multiple times vs. Pitt. He's been a warrior but Father Time is undefeated.
Dishonorable mention: Wilson, Hankerson, Cundiff, rounds 3-5 in the past 2 draft classes

Players who shouldn't be back next year
Not a comprehensive list but these players (who get regular time) have done nothing to warrant staying on our and in some cases, any NFL roster:
Hall, Doughty, M. Williams, Royster, Banks (ugh), Polumbus, C. Griffin

Who did I miss in any category?

[Chico23231]

Add to your players who shouldnt be here next year: Gomes, Aldrick Robinson, Jamal Brown, Rex Grossman

[Paintrain]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

Add to your players who shouldnt be here next year: Gomes, Aldrick Robinson, Jamal Brown, Rex Grossman

You know, I'm not sure why Gomes isn't getting on the field. Is he that much worse than what's been out there? He must be terrible because I think Doughty is one of the least athletic players in the league and he starts ahead of Gomes. I don't want to bash Doughty too much but he's always a step slow in coverage, a step slow in run support making the tackle just after the first down marker, a beat slow in dissecting the play.

Can't disagree with the rest of your additions.

[Chico23231]

Originally Posted by Paintrain

You know, I'm not sure why Gomes isn't getting on the field. Is he that much worse than what's been out there? He must be terrible because I think Doughty is one of the least athletic players in the league and he starts ahead of Gomes. I don't want to bash Doughty too much but he's always a step slow in coverage, a step slow in run support making the tackle just after the first down marker, a beat slow in dissecting the play.

Can't disagree with the rest of your additions.

Gomes got abused in coverage when he started and on the field. He is ok in run support, but Ive seen he has also studied the Rocky McIntosh "Book of Bad Angles" which he takes alot as well. Doesnt have the speed or knowledge for an NFL safety.

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by chico23231

gomes got abused in coverage when he started and on the field. He is ok in run support, but ive seen he has also studied the rocky mcintosh "book of bad angles" which he takes alot as well. Doesnt have the speed or knowledge for an nfl safety.

+1.

[HailGreen28]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

Add to your players who shouldnt be here next year: Gomes, Aldrick Robinson, Jamal Brown, Rex Grossman

Why has Gomes not stepped up? All these injuries were a golden opportunity for him.

[Lotus]

Originally Posted by HailGreen28

Why has Gomes not stepped up? All these injuries were a golden opportunity for him.

Yep. I've been a Gomes fan. It is sad that he let his opportunity slip.

[punch it in]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

Add to your players who shouldnt be here next year: Gomes, Aldrick Robinson, Jamal Brown, Rex Grossman

Josh Wilson



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Chico23231]

Originally Posted by punch it in

Josh Wilson



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Not giving up on Wilson. Think it has to do more with his displeasure with Haslett. I dont know for sure if he dislike him, but more of a sense. I think Wilson could play solid as a no.2 or at least in the slot. I say bring him back.

Pain, I agree with alot of what you said, especially the surprises. Im gonna disagree with Kerrigan. Think he gets the motor going after the bye.

[skinsfaninok]

Griffin, morris and trent williams are the only guys having a good season on this team. Ryan kerrigan is no where to be found and that secondary is embarrassing.

[Paintrain]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

Griffin, morris and trent williams are the only guys having a good season on this team. Ryan kerrigan is no where to be found and that secondary is embarrassing.

You don't think that Morgan is having a good season?

[jamf]

Originally Posted by Paintrain

You don't think that Morgan is having a good season?

I don't!
He is getting paid to be a #2 WR and only has 309 yards more than halfway through the season. No TDs and atleast 6 drops.
That's not even factoring in his mental mistake.
35 yards per game average is not acceptable for a starter.

[Paintrain]

Originally Posted by jamf

I don't!
He is getting paid to be a #2 WR and only has 309 yards more than halfway through the season. No TDs and atleast 6 drops.
That's not even factoring in his mental mistake.
35 yards per game average is not acceptable for a starter.

I really never understood what someone's paycheck has to do with anything. Victor Cruz is being paid like a street free agent. If he was making Calvin Johnson money would that make his play any more or less valuable to his team's results on Sunday?

I'm not really looking at stats, I'm watching the games and I've been happy with what Morgan has brought so far. He's been relatively consistent with his hands, get some YAC, fights for the ball and extra yards. If I recall he's had 2 TD called back on penalties. Without viable options such as Garçon and Davis, he's stepped up IMO.

[44Deezel]

Originally Posted by Paintrain

I really never understood what someone's paycheck has to do with anything. Victor Cruz is being paid like a street free agent. If he was making Calvin Johnson money would that make his play any more or less valuable to his team's results on Sunday?

I'm not really looking at stats, I'm watching the games and I've been happy with what Morgan has brought so far. He's been relatively consistent with his hands, get some YAC, fights for the ball and extra yards. If I recall he's had 2 TD called back on penalties. Without viable options such as Garçon and Davis, he's stepped up IMO.

He's a good blocker as well.

[Evilgrin]

Players who will be gone for sure are Hall & Brown, there contracts are whats keeping them on the team. They couldn't afford the cap hit, by cutting them this year.