my latest draft thoughts

[diehardskin2982]

as the draft gets closer and its becomes more apparent that we will get our new talent on the team through the draft I have come up with a draft strategy that we can use to address all our need and get some value, I will lay it out there and ask the board to tell me what you think.

1: Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie CB Tennessee ST
why?: Springs is aging and in the twilight of his career and Rogers is comming of a tremendous injury, smoot is good but outside of those players there is few that can play right now in the NFL. It is time to look to the future and cromartie can use a year to learn from Smoot and Springs. He already is working with Green! He has blazing speed and great cover skills he could spend this season in the nickle and return punts.

2:MOVE UP!: Trevors laws DT Nortre Dame
Why: He is a force in the interior, high motor and would compliment the large Montgomery as well as add to a pass rush up the middle

3:Trade pick to move up

3(comp):Jerome Simpson WR Coastal Carolina
Why?: he has size, okay speed and can jump throgh the roof. he was a touchdown scoring machine for his team percise route runner solid #2 comparison: Reggie Wayne *Biggest hands and reach in the combine*

5:John Greco G/T Toledo
Why: He has the all the intangibles and could do well under the right coach~ who we have on staff currently

6:Marcus Monk WR Arkansas-
Why?:u guys know who he is and what he bring so I won't get into it...

7:Marcus Dixon De Hampton
Why?: great production while in school, had a minor transgression in highschool but was later turned around. He can rush the passer and voted hardest worker/ mvp of team.

7 (comp): Bernard Morris QB Marshal-
Why?: Athletic QB, good 3rd stringer nice arm won't challenge for the starting job.

7 (comp): Bobbie Williams Bethune Cookman S
Why: Has the motor and intensity of a blue chiper he is worth the late round pick.HE hits like a monster look him up on you tube!

Honorable mention: Jamie Silva S Boston College- the kid has heart and would work well with landry.

So tell me what ya think!

[billyredskin]

I see a wide receiver in the first round...Limas Sweed I would think. After that...I am torn. We need to build up depth on D-Line, Cornerback and Safety. Not sure which one we go for in the second round...I assume they will rate players with an overall number (regardless of position) and the highest rated player available when the 2nd round pick comes up will get the call. My hope is that we get a kick-ass DE or DT and also a talented cornerback by the end of the 3rd round. And, assuming we actually do get a compensatory 3rd or 4th round pick...why not grab a QB? Booty, Ainge, Josh Johnson and Colt Brennan are all projected to be available in the 3-4-5 rounds. I am not sold on Campbell yet...he made too many mistakes at the wrong time last season for us to not think about another young QB for Zorn to tutor and press Campbell. Competition is good at the QB position...may the best man win.

[Eknox]

Cromartie is predicted to be gone waaaay before our pick, as is Talib. Of course I'd love to get either ,but I don't see it happening without trading up.

[Dirtbag59]

Posted this in another tread,but I guess this is also a good place to put it:

So I guess my draft/what I want yet realistically see the Redskins doing goes as follows. I think at this point I have to many DE's but we'll see.

1st - Mike Jenkins - CB/S - South Florida (I mean I guess it's kind of like Miami)

2nd - Jordy Nelson - WR - Kansas (Only Reciever worth a look IMO after the 1st round, and despite his 3rd round grade I doubt the skins will be able to get him without trading up in the 3rd round, which is impossible without unloding one of next years picks)

3rd - Robert Felton - G - Arkansas (Reminds me a lot of Dockery and personally I believe hes a big part of the reason Arkansas had success running the ball)

3rd Comp - Wallace Gilbery - DE - Alabama (My favorite sleeper with 10 sacks and 27 TFL)

5th - Dennis Dixon - QB - Oregon or Colt Brenen - QB - Hawaii (Grrrrr do we really need to waste a pick on a QB)

6th - Rudolph Hardie - DE - Howard (Thanks to ThatGuy for bringing him to my attention)

7th - Jamie Silva - S - BC (Overachiever that might be picked about 10 picks ahead of where I'm projecting him here)

7th - Marcus Dixon - DE/DT - Hampton (Would give the Skins that 3 technique they're looking for)

7th - Marcus Monk - WR - Arkansas (He's like.....huge, but also productive especially for a 7th round pick)

UDFA - Andrew Crummy - G - Maryland (Stephon Heyer.....Andrew Crummy, see the pattern?)

Also as far as Guard is concerned, we've taken the 5th/6th round route in the past, and to my knowledge not one of those guys ever developed into anything. The only guy thats ever emerged is Stephon Heyer, and as you can see I predict the Redskins continuing the trend of developing an UDFA from Maryland for the second year in a row. This time around I believe its imparitive to draft a lineman within the first 3 rounds.

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by Dirtbag359

Posted this in another tread,but I guess this is also a good place to put it:

So I guess my draft/what I want yet realistically see the Redskins doing goes as follows. I think at this point I have to many DE's but we'll see.

1st - Mike Jenkins - CB/S - South Florida (I mean I guess it's kind of like Miami)

2nd - Jordy Nelson - WR - Kansas (Only Reciever worth a look IMO after the 1st round, and despite his 3rd round grade I doubt the skins will be able to get him without trading up in the 3rd round, which is impossible without unloding one of next years picks)

3rd - Robert Felton - G - Arkansas (Reminds me a lot of Dockery and personally I believe hes a big part of the reason Arkansas had success running the ball)

3rd Comp - Wallace Gilbery - DE - Alabama (My favorite sleeper with 10 sacks and 27 TFL)

5th - Dennis Dixon - QB - Oregon or Colt Brenen - QB - Hawaii (Grrrrr do we really need to waste a pick on a QB)

6th - Rudolph Hardie - DE - Howard (Thanks to ThatGuy for bringing him to my attention)

7th - Jamie Silva - S - BC (Overachiever that might be picked about 10 picks ahead of where I'm projecting him here)

7th - Marcus Dixon - DE/DT - Hampton (Would give the Skins that 3 technique they're looking for)

7th - Marcus Monk - WR - Arkansas (He's like.....huge, but also productive especially for a 7th round pick)

UDFA - Andrew Crummy - G - Maryland (Stephon Heyer.....Andrew Crummy, see the pattern?)

Also as far as Guard is concerned, we've taken the 5th/6th round route in the past, and to my knowledge not one of those guys ever developed into anything. The only guy thats ever emerged is Stephon Heyer, and as you can see I predict the Redskins continuing the trend of developing an UDFA from Maryland for the second year in a row. This time around I believe its imparitive to draft a lineman within the first 3 rounds.

Talentwise, this would be an impressive haul, but I'm a little nervous because you have us relying on some big question marks at absolutely critical positions.

There's no doubt that Jenkins and Jordy Nelson fill two gaps on our team right now, but those are hardly the biggest gaps. There's a big probability that if we go this route, we have a 50% chance or better of not improving the team over the long haul here, and IMO the chance to land low risk talent on the edges does not justify taking potshot chances at filling long term holes on the lines.

The issue here is that if we are to assume that Crummney, Hardie, Gilberry, Felton are the solution on our line issues, we have to play them as if we are just assuming that they will play like first or second rounders. We don't have to do that with a third corner or a third receivers.

Of course, if you are right here and those guys turn out to be above average NFL starters, you've just made a hell of a draft. But is that something you want to risk the future of the team under Zorn and Campbell on?

I just don't have the cajones to pull that

[Dirtbag59]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

Talentwise, this would be an impressive haul, but I'm a little nervous because you have us relying on some big question marks at absolutely critical positions.

There's no doubt that Jenkins and Jordy Nelson fill two gaps on our team right now, but those are hardly the biggest gaps. There's a big probability that if we go this route, we have a 50% chance or better of not improving the team over the long haul here, and IMO the chance to land low risk talent on the edges does not justify taking potshot chances at filling long term holes on the lines.

The issue here is that if we are to assume that Crummney, Hardie, Gilberry, Felton are the solution on our line issues, we have to play them as if we are just assuming that they will play like first or second rounders. We don't have to do that with a third corner or a third receivers.

Of course, if you are right here and those guys turn out to be above average NFL starters, you've just made a hell of a draft. But is that something you want to risk the future of the team under Zorn and Campbell on?

I just don't have the cajones to pull that

Well the draft is a hybrid of what I want and what I think the front office will try to do. So far I know the following.

1. The DC thinks that building a defense begins at CB

2. Danny wants a big reciever and after Nelson there are no quality big men available. Plus Cerrato has been quoted by members here as saying that no reciever has been given a first round grade by our front office. On top of that the Redskins lost out on the Caldwell and Hacket sweepstakes.

3. We need a LDE that can possibly be a starter down the road.

4. The Skins don't shy away from drafting two guys at a particular spot as seen with DT and LB in recent years.

5. The Skins want a DT with pass rush ability, and I'll admit I didn't address that directly but two of those guys could possibly move inside and play the 3 technique.

6. The FO values a swing offenisve lineman that could possibly start in a year or two and have been pretty sucesful finding guys in the 3rd round.

I'm with you, I want to see the Redskins adress the line. However based on the philosophies of the FO and coaching staff I put together the mock draft that you see here in this thread. If it was up to me then you would see a draft with.....actually ****, it's to hard to think for myself.

[memphisskin]

Dirtbag,

Love the selections, Marcus Monk would be a helluva sleeper. But you may have too much time on ur hands....

[Dirtbag59]

Originally Posted by memphisskin

Dirtbag,

Love the selections, Marcus Monk would be a helluva sleeper. But you may have too much time on ur hands....

Lol, maybe I do, but I'm stuck at work in my schools tech building these days so posting here usually helps the time fly by. Besides I rarely post during the season so it all evens out.

[GTripp0012]

Jenkins would be a good value pick at 21, but I think if we choose to take a corner in the first round, then we definately should spend the next two picks addressing line. The second round is really high for a guy who, very optimistically, projects as a No. 2 receiver.

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by diehardskin2982

as the draft gets closer and its becomes more apparent that we will get our new talent on the team through the draft I have come up with a draft strategy that we can use to address all our need and get some value, I will lay it out there and ask the board to tell me what you think.

1: Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie CB Tennessee ST
why?: Springs is aging and in the twilight of his career and Rogers is comming of a tremendous injury, smoot is good but outside of those players there is few that can play right now in the NFL. It is time to look to the future and cromartie can use a year to learn from Smoot and Springs. He already is working with Green! He has blazing speed and great cover skills he could spend this season in the nickle and return punts.

2:MOVE UP!: Trevors laws DT Nortre Dame
Why: He is a force in the interior, high motor and would compliment the large Montgomery as well as add to a pass rush up the middle

3:Trade pick to move up

3(comp):Jerome Simpson WR Coastal Carolina
Why?: he has size, okay speed and can jump throgh the roof. he was a touchdown scoring machine for his team percise route runner solid #2 comparison: Reggie Wayne *Biggest hands and reach in the combine*

5:John Greco G/T Toledo
Why: He has the all the intangibles and could do well under the right coach~ who we have on staff currently

6:Marcus Monk WR Arkansas-
Why?:u guys know who he is and what he bring so I won't get into it...

7:Marcus Dixon De Hampton
Why?: great production while in school, had a minor transgression in highschool but was later turned around. He can rush the passer and voted hardest worker/ mvp of team.

7 (comp): Bernard Morris QB Marshal-
Why?: Athletic QB, good 3rd stringer nice arm won't challenge for the starting job.

7 (comp): Bobbie Williams Bethune Cookman S
Why: Has the motor and intensity of a blue chiper he is worth the late round pick.HE hits like a monster look him up on you tube!

Honorable mention: Jamie Silva S Boston College- the kid has heart and would work well with landry.

So tell me what ya think!

I think the trade up for a player like Laws is a good idea if we fill a hole like Guard by taking Branden Albert at 23. However, if we choose to take the value and select Cromartie at 21, I would definately argue against a trade up because we still have massive needs on the OL that we can't solve if we trade the 3rd round pick.

And I would love Trevor Laws, and I do think Cerrato values him highly. But he won't give up the third rounder to get him if he needs the pick to address a need position.

[GTripp0012]

Well, can we assume anything about the FO's tendencies? Anything teams say at this point has to be taken with a grain of salt.

Blache said Corners are the cornerstone of defense, but he didn't say he thought we had a need there. Reading between the lines, I'd say it's less likely that we take a CB in the first.

If the value is there, I'm totally 100% all for it. But only if we grade a particular corner out as a top 10 player. If we grade him out as a top ten player, and he's there at 21, then by golly we better jump on him.

I don't think there's any chance we address WR before the third round. I mean, consider that the only FA we brought in and offered a contract to (under the assumption that we were trying to add him to the depth chart) was a WR. Assuming the team had a draft plan before free agency began, it's the reasonable conclusion to say that we weren't going to chase Hackett, and then also pick a WR on day 1.

Obviously, the logical conclusion is that we then put a majority of our scouting hours at the combine into players at other positions. Meaning that unless there's a great value on a WR, we will probably re-evaluate the remaining prospects after day one before considering spending a pick on one. To me, this is the closest train of thought I can have to the team's stance on WRs.

Obviously, we will select one at some point on day 2. We definately have the depth need there. I just don't see a lot of cues pointing to using a day one pick on a WR.

Ultimately, the Skins will make three selections where they will depend on the player to factor in to the long term plans. After that, you've just got to do the smart thing and just pick guys in the late rounds at any position that have a chance to contribute. Makes sense to grab the LB that fell over whatever is left at DL simply because we have a need there.

I totally follow your train of thought here, hopefully, I've added some deductive insight. Maybe I'm totally wrong, but at least I feel like I'm on to something. At the least, that in itself is good

[GTripp0012]

Here are all the Day One draft picks for the Bears on defense in the Blache era:

Russell Davis-DT North Carolina
Brian Urlacher-LB New Mexico
Mike Brown-S Nebraska
Dustin Lyman-LB Wake Forest
Roosevelt Williams-CB Tuskeegee
Michael Haynes-DE Penn State
Charles Tillman-CB Louisiana Lafeyette
Lance Briggs-LB Arizona

Obviously the Bears did not put any particular premium on DBs while he was the coordinator there. I don't know how much draft influence he had, but it looks like they started in the front seven and tried to complete it with DBs, or at the very least spread the picks around the defense.

The success rate was a mixed bag. Urlacher, Brown, Briggs, and Tillman became the foundation of the great Bears defense of this decade. Williams, Haynes, Davis, and Lyman made zero impact in the league.

While I generally agree with Blache's assessment that Corners are the staple of any pass defense (and the importance of pass d trumps that of run d, that much we know), it doesn't help if you spend a high draft pick on a corner who is misvalued (thanks, Carlos).

I know you don't particularly advocate the value of corners, and are just going off what Blache says, but I don't think that statement makes it likely that the Skins will use a first round pick on a Corner unless the guy they want drops to them.

[ChickenMonkey]

as the draft gets closer and its becomes more apparent that we will get our new talent on the team through the draft I have come up with a draft strategy that we can use to address all our need and get some value, I will lay it out there and ask the board to tell me what you think.

1st Round CB Aquib Talib
2nd Round WR Mario Manningham
3rd Round DE JAson Jones
3rd Round SS Josh Barrett
5th Round OLB Ezra Butler
6th Round CB Jack Ikegwonu(ingured before combine....great value here
7th Round OG Chris McDuffie(huge...
7th Round OG/T Pedro Sosa

Good Use of every pick..................

[30gut]

Originally Posted by diehardskin2982

7 (comp): Bobbie Williams Bethune Cookman S
Why: Has the motor and intensity of a blue chiper he is worth the late round pick.HE hits like a monster look him up on you tube!

Honorable mention: Jamie Silva S Boston College- the kid has heart and would work well with landry.

So tell me what ya think!

Interesting picks. Here's another D-AA safety for you to look at: Corey Lynch(freakin interception magnet) the best safety in D-1 AA
YouTube - Corey Lynch #47

Corey*Lynch, FS, Appalachian State - 2008 NFL Draft Scout Profile, Powered by The SportsXchange

ASU’s Corey Lynch Heads Final Buchanan Watch List - SoConSports.com—Official Web Site of The Southern Conference

[SeanTaylor21]

Originally Posted by 30gut

Interesting picks. Here's another D-AA safety for you to look at: Corey Lynch(freakin interception magnet) the best safety in D-1 AA
YouTube - Corey Lynch #47

Corey*Lynch, FS, Appalachian State - 2008 NFL Draft Scout Profile, Powered by The SportsXchange

ASU’s Corey Lynch Heads Final Buchanan Watch List - SoConSports.com—Official Web Site of The Southern Conference

I wouldn't mind drafting that kid, he looks good in that video, but his competition didn't look all that amazing.