I have a question for all of my Redskins fans and fantasy fans out there.

[artmonkforhallofamein07]

Now would you trade Aaron Rodgers and Terrel Owens for Jason Campbell and Santana Moss? I am leaning on making the trade, but I am scared of having to many redskins. I already have CP and CC. Should I pull the trigger or am I risking my fantasy team to be a redskins homer? Anybody have any suggestions or advice.

Now my logic behind it is Aaron is possibly hurt and T.O. my be ready for a big blow up, but I am sure he will have a good game against the bengals sunday. Help me out guys.

[Hog1]

While I think that TO and Rodgers are much more of a known quantity, Moss, and JC are JUST beginning to gather momentum (that's the unknown part). Do you risk what might be, for what is.
I think the Skins are going to roll! BUT, that's the homer in me.
Who's got the schedule to TORCH some opponents?
AND, you can get burned having to many from one team

[EternalEnigma21]

Wouldn't do either. U will get screwed if our offense has a bad game.

[Monkeydad]

Originally Posted by EternalEnigma21

Wouldn't do either. U will get screwed if our offense has a bad game.

He can start another QB when matchups look bad. If Campbell still has a good game on his bench, it is likely Moss will so it won't be a total loss of those points.

[artmonkforhallofamein07]

Well we might have a tough game next week vs the iggles but we have some easier games after that with St loius and all the other 2 NFC WEST teams. SF got torched. We do play the AFC North soon so the Ravens and Steelers games will probably be down games but the bengals and browns should be high scoring games.

Like I said though have we seen the best from Rodgers already? Is he going to be hurt for a while? Does a partially seperated shoulder really hurt a QBs throwing arm?

Right now SM is a better scorer than TO so I am really ready to pop off this trade.

[artmonkforhallofamein07]

As far as RB go I also have Gore, Parker, and Westbrook. WR are Fitzgerald, Andre Johson, Hank Basket, Eddie Royal, and TO. TE are Bo Scaife and K2. And my other QBS are Big Ben and Trent Edwards.

I really do not know what to do that is why I am asking for some advice. I think our best 2 guys on our team right now as far as fantasy are SM and JC. And they have been outplaying Rodgers and TO.

[Monkeydad]

Honestly, I would do it from a pure fantasy perspective.

Rodgers doesn't look like he can make it through a season healthy. Remember last season when Favre got hurt, Aaron came in and broke a bone, Favre had to start the next week hurt? He's banged up this year too.

Owens is started to behave in the way he did at the end of his stay in Philly and in SF.


Campbell looks incredibly efficient and getting better every week while Moss is having a monster year. You KNOW that Moss will still get looks all year.

DO it.

[GhettoDogAllStars]

I got a trade question myself...

I have:
QB C. Palmer
QB M. Hasselbeck
WR L. Fitzgerald
WR M. Colston
WR L. Evans
WR L. Coles
WR E. Royal

I'm considering this trade:
QB E. Manning for QB C. Palmer and WR L. Coles

I'm ready to do it, but I wanted to know if you guys think it's fair. It's my sister's team, and her first year in the league, so I don't want to rip her off.

Her other QB is P. Manning, and her WRs are H. Ward, S. Smith, and R. Moss. We start 1 QB and up to 2-3 WRs, so she doesn't have much WR depth. Also, both Mannings have had their Byes already.

What do you guys think? Is it fair? I want to do it, but I don't know if she should.

[DIRTEE]

Originally Posted by GhettoDogAllStars

I got a trade question myself...

I'm ready to do it, but I wanted to know if you guys think it's fair. It's my sister's team, and her first year in the league, so I don't want to rip her off.

Sure you don't!!!

[That Guy]

palmer is probably worthless this year, but coles probably helps her more than a backup qb, even though peyton is having a bad start.

[Monkeydad]

If you can get rid of Palmer in any way...DO IT.

I gave him another week last week and he got hurt and won't be right for the rest of the year from the sounds of it.

He's trash this year.

I just outright dropped him for Garrard and I pity anyone who adds him to their team.

[mredskins]

Originally Posted by artmonkforhallofamein07

Now would you trade Aaron Rodgers and Terrel Owens for Jason Campbell and Santana Moss? I am leaning on making the trade, but I am scared of having to many redskins. I already have CP and CC. Should I pull the trigger or am I risking my fantasy team to be a redskins homer? Anybody have any suggestions or advice.

Now my logic behind it is Aaron is possibly hurt and T.O. my be ready for a big blow up, but I am sure he will have a good game against the bengals sunday. Help me out guys.

If you pull this trade I bet you lose 11/9, you won't have any players. don't do this this trade you have two many players veing for the same ball on Sunday. No way CC,CP,SM and JC all give you good numbers in the same week, even if the Skins have a good game.

[MTK]

Palmer could be a good matchup against that weak Dallas secondary this week. I'm not sure how much of a concern is elbow is though.

[Skins4L]

maybe PORTIS & CAMPBELL for OWEN RODGERS at this point anyways.

[JGisLordOfTheRings]

Originally Posted by Skins4L

maybe PORTIS & CAMPBELL for OWEN RODGERS at this point anyways.

That would be decent but nobody in their right f-ing mind would trade away CP now....