Quote:
Originally Posted by NC_Skins
You had a few chirping about his performance last night as if it was MVP worthy. It wasn't. Not even close. I understand he's a HoF QB, but lets call a spade a spade.
I wouldn't put AD over Manning simply for the fact that the Vikings will most likely miss the playoffs. MVPs are generally not given to guys who miss the playoffs. Can you name me one MVP in the NFL that's won the award and missed the playoffs.
Manning will get it because 1) he was out a year and still beasting 2) He has a better record 3) His has the numbers to back it (better than Tom's)
|
He has a better record and arguably the softest schedule in the league. They played atlanta, Houston, and you guessed it - new england and lost them all. Manning is having an incredible bounce back year. Just incredible. He also has a much better defense than Brady. I could make an argument for either of them. I would really have to dissect the numbers if i actually had a vote. As for mvp's who miss the playoffs u may be rite, but personally i think thats a joke. If a guy plays on a team that is 8-8 or 9-7 but they would be 3-13 without him than that is a valuable player. Playoffs or not.
Edit: Brady has more yards and one less td. We will have to see how it all shakes out.