Thought I'd throw my
Carter, complete f-ing moron. I hope he never gets in the Hall.
I remember one year for the Jimmy V Foundation auction there was a package to come to ESPN and break down film with Jaws. If that ever comes up again I would certainly bid on that. Dilfer, Schlereth and MW are also very good. Agree with SS on Golic, he's hand-cuffed on M & M, but when he does the occasional college game he's very good.
Hoge is irritating, but he does some good breakdowns.
Not a Chucky fan, his QB breakdowns to me are a lot more style over substance. He is entertaining and good in the MNF booth though and the team is very good for the first time in a while.
Mayock on NFLN and Aikman are solid. Buck irritates the hell out of me, as does Collinsworth. I don't mind Joey T., you just have to realize he's a homer going in.
Anyone not mentioned....meh.
EDIT: Cowherd is annoying at times, but he's pretty good on NCAA FB.