Quote:
Originally Posted by SBXVII
The comparisons are because people are wanting to use STATS. I'm not a stats person and I'll say McNabb is most likely better then JC, but the stats don't show it. If you start when McNabb came into the league then he will blow JC out of the water, but if you use last yrs stats or the last couple yrs stats cause that shows a better evaluation of what your getting now then JC's stats are comparable.
Plus JC had a horrible OL to play behind, a bad HC, a bad scheme, and not as good of WR's. The only consulation I can think of is Shanahan will have a better system, coached up WR's, hopefully a decent OL.
|
Comparing these two is a joke, I mean really.
Donovan McNabb: Career Stats
Jason Campbell: Career Stats
We shouldn't even be talking about these 2 in the same sentence. One guy is one of the top guys in the league, the other guy we can't even give away at this point.
Stats aside, anyone who tries to say that JC is in the same ballpark as McNabb is simply kidding themselves.