Quote:
Originally Posted by Trample the Elderly
Don't compare McNabb to Soup. McNabb is a good QB. Soup is an average QB at best.
|
Well, right, but how much of that is because the Philly defense manages to be great every year.
If McNabb had a below .500 win percentage, but was the exact same quarterback, would people still say he was good? I really don't think they would, though certainly, I could be wrong.