Commanders Post at The Warpath - View Single Post

bedlamVR · 08-09-2004, 07:11 AM

I think it is way too early to consider Vick as a great. He has good skills but Caulpepper has done more for his team with similar skills and being a QB is more than physical skills it is being able to lift a team which is down like Elway or Montana. With them back there the game was never over.

Of the current players who could be considered as great include Trent Green, not only for his Chiefs carrear which he has Priest Holmes to hand the ball off to but when he turned the Skins 0-7 season (6-10) round with Skip Hicks to hand off to and the likes of Brad Badger in the decimated O-Line.

Others include Payton Manning of course andMatt Hastelbeck, Dante Culpepper and Steve McNair.

Players like Brady and McNabb i think benifit from having an overwhelming defence and just and overall team effort. Farve shoild have hung it up long ago he is like Santa in a green bay uniform he threw away the playoff game against the Eagles last year and everytime the ball goes up it is 50-50 pick or compleation. I think it is a shame because it is tarnishing his reputation.

It is stil way to early to make any kind of decision on Ramsey, Carr, Harrington, Boller, Eli Manning etc but they could be the better QB of the next ten years.

08-09-2004, 07:11 AM	#26
bedlamVR Special Teams Join Date: Apr 2004 Posts: 389	I think it is way too early to consider Vick as a great. He has good skills but Caulpepper has done more for his team with similar skills and being a QB is more than physical skills it is being able to lift a team which is down like Elway or Montana. With them back there the game was never over. Of the current players who could be considered as great include Trent Green, not only for his Chiefs carrear which he has Priest Holmes to hand the ball off to but when he turned the Skins 0-7 season (6-10) round with Skip Hicks to hand off to and the likes of Brad Badger in the decimated O-Line. Others include Payton Manning of course andMatt Hastelbeck, Dante Culpepper and Steve McNair. Players like Brady and McNabb i think benifit from having an overwhelming defence and just and overall team effort. Farve shoild have hung it up long ago he is like Santa in a green bay uniform he threw away the playoff game against the Eagles last year and everytime the ball goes up it is 50-50 pick or compleation. I think it is a shame because it is tarnishing his reputation. It is stil way to early to make any kind of decision on Ramsey, Carr, Harrington, Boller, Eli Manning etc but they could be the better QB of the next ten years.