Re: Come up with a new name for the Redskins
 

[quote=MTK;1289205]To me it looks like a generic logo from Madden when you move your franchise to another city. But either way I think a NFL team should do better.[/quote]

Like a plain blue star or the letter G or the letters NY? Now that's generic.

Re: Come up with a new name for the Redskins
 

The thing about a logo is you want it to stick out, like the Redskins logo did, Dallas , GB Etc. When you saw our old logo, everyone knew who it was. I'm talking about the avg sports fan that doesn't watch football 24/7

Re: Come up with a new name for the Redskins
 

[IMG]https://images2.minutemediacdn.com/image/fetch/c_fill,g_auto,f_auto,h_2133,w_3200/https%3A%2F%2Friggosrag.com%2Fwp-content%2Fuploads%2Fgetty-images%2F2016%2F04%2F1196241788.jpeg[/IMG]

Sorry but this will always be a top 10 LOGO in any sport

Re: Come up with a new name for the Redskins
 

[quote=skinsfaninok;1289208]The thing about a logo is you want it to stick out, like the Redskins logo did, Dallas , GB Etc. When you saw our old logo, everyone knew who it was. I'm talking about the avg sports fan that doesn't watch football 24/7[/quote]

Everyone knows those logos because they've been around forever.

Re: Come up with a new name for the Redskins
 

[quote=irish;1289207]Like a plain blue star or the letter G or the letters NY? Now that's generic.[/quote]

You're really comparing iconic logos like the Cowboys or Packers to that San Antonio one lol? If you like it that's great, personally I hope ours ends up looking better than that.

Re: Come up with a new name for the Redskins
 

[quote=irish;1289210]Everyone knows those logos because they've been around forever.[/quote]

Yeah but even the younger generation knows the cowboys star..

Re: Come up with a new name for the Redskins
 

[quote=MTK;1289211]You're really comparing iconic logos like the Cowboys or Packers to that San Antonio one lol? If you like it that's great, personally I hope ours ends up looking better than that.[/quote]

As I think about it they are iconic because they are generic. When it comes to a logo generic and plain is better. The problem with the SA logo isn't that its generic, the problem is its too busy. There's too much going on and the logo looks "forced".

Re: Come up with a new name for the Redskins
 

[quote=skinsfaninok;1289212]Yeah but even the younger generation knows the cowboys star..[/quote]

Of course they do, its been around for decades.

Re: Come up with a new name for the Redskins
 

Touché

Re: Come up with a new name for the Redskins
 

I was thinking about this last night, ultimately what's more important the new name or the new logo?

Seems to me a cool new name could be ruined by a shitty logo. But a lame name could be saved by a really cool logo.

Hopefully they'll hit a HR with both, but if you could only have one what would you want? A great name or a great logo?

Re: Come up with a new name for the Redskins
 

[QUOTE=MTK;1289337]I was thinking about this last night, ultimately what's more important the new name or the new logo?



Seems to me a cool new name could be ruined by a shitty logo. But a lame name could be saved by a really cool logo.



Hopefully they'll hit a HR with both, but if you could only have one what would you want? A great name or a great logo?[/QUOTE]The logo and the "fan connect" terms are more important than the actual name because they create that visual and emotional bond to the team. "Go Team" isn't as powerful as "go pack go".
Likewise a cluttered logo (like the San Antonio one) doesn't build that deep link, to many strings pulled at once without a real focal point.

Sent from my SM-G973U using Tapatalk

Re: Come up with a new name for the Redskins
 

[quote=MTK;1289337]I was thinking about this last night, ultimately what's more important the new name or the new logo?

Seems to me a cool new name could be ruined by a shitty logo. But a lame name could be saved by a really cool logo.

Hopefully they'll hit a HR with both, but if you could only have one what would you want? A great name or a great logo?[/quote]

I don't know if I could say the logo matters more than the name, because the name determines a lot of what the logo and team identity can be.

What I can say though is that a very good logo would help me get on board with a name I don't like.

Re: Come up with a new name for the Redskins
 

[quote=FrenchSkin;1289341]I don't know if I could say the logo matters more than the name, because the name determines a lot of what the logo and team identity can be.

[B]What I can say though is that a very good logo would help me get on board with a name I don't like[/B].[/quote]

That's what I'm thinking with a rather bland possibility like Commanders. A killer logo would bring it all together.

Re: Come up with a new name for the Redskins
 

[QUOTE=MTK;1289347]That's what I'm thinking with a rather bland possibility like Commanders. A killer logo would bring it all together.[/QUOTE]I get what you are saying but picking a bland name and trying to spruce it up with the logo would be so Dan snyderesque. Like putting makeup on a pig. There is no reason the name AND logo shouldn't be a winner. Especially if they have devoted the time, energy and money to the selection as they imply they have.

Sent from my SM-G973U using Tapatalk

Re: Come up with a new name for the Redskins
 

[quote=CRedskinsRule;1289353]I get what you are saying but picking a bland name and trying to spruce it up with the logo would be so Dan snyderesque. Like putting makeup on a pig. There is no reason the name AND logo shouldn't be a winner. Especially if they have devoted the time, energy and money to the selection as they imply they have.

Sent from my SM-G973U using Tapatalk[/quote]

I'm just saying that no matter what the name is, there will be people that won't like it. One person's clean and simple is another's generic and boring. So for those that don't like the name maybe the logo saves it from being a total fail for them.