Re: Hall to be replaced?
 

[quote=WillH;226575]:madani: (I tried to find a [I]shit-my-pants[/I] smilie, but none exists... someone should really get on that)[/quote]
:lol:
That's what I look like before, during and after I crap my pants.

Hall's injury prone to be certain. I like Edinger. He's made a couple of decent clutch kicks, including a game-winner against us at Chicago a few years ago. His stats may not be the best in the world but he did kick in Chicago, aka The Windy City.

Re: Hall to be replaced?
 

Given Hall's age and his chronic leg problems, I think his career may be done.

My money is on Todd Peterson.

Re: Hall to be replaced?
 

[quote=Mattyk72;226628]Given Hall's age and his chronic leg problems, I think his career may be done.

My money is on Todd Peterson.[/quote]

I agree; Hall is done. Peterson would be all right.

Re: Hall to be replaced?
 

Thank God! Hall has been 50-50 from 40+ for years, and I grew tired of seeing his kickoffs (when he was doing it) only get to the 5 or 10 yard line...(setting up our opp with great field position). we are lucky he's out...next target, Brunell...

Re: Hall to be replaced?
 

this is one mistake i will hang on the coaching staff. this should have been addressed in the off season. now we are left with a pile of nobodies

Re: Hall to be replaced?
 

It's about time we geta replacement. I'd be happy with Novak OR Peterson. I like Novak better, he's younger and a Terp. :)

Peterson has had a good career. 79.4% on FGs and 99.1% on PATs. His career long is 54 but he's had a ton of kicks over 50.

Peterson is 73% from 40-49 yards on his career and 43% from 50+ yards (not bad). He's 36 though, 4 years OLDER than Hall.

Hall is 59% career from 40-49 and 46% from 50+ amazingly. That 40-49 yard kick % is ugly though.

In Novak's short career, he's 1/1 from 40-49 and has never kicked over 50 yards. 80% (8/10) in FGs and 100% (15/15) in PATs. He should last a LOT longer though. The kid is just 25 years old.

Re: Hall to be replaced?
 

I have been a backer of Hall but if this is true its time to part ways. This brings up another question. We where down by two TD's and faced with 4th and short why didn't Gibbs go for the 4th down instead of going for the FG? With him knowing Hall had a tired leg this call is even more questionable now.

Re: Hall to be replaced?
 

[quote=firstdown;226687]I have been a backer of Hall but if this is true its time to part ways. This brings up another question. We where down by two TD's and faced with 4th and short why didn't Gibbs go for the 4th down instead of going for the FG? With him knowing Hall had a tired leg this call is even more questionable now.[/quote]

Gibbs has always been one to take points over chances. He's never been one to risk 4th-down conversions. That's just how he coaches. Some coaches take chances and fail more often than not, Gibbs has always been conservative when it comes to that.

Re: Hall to be replaced?
 

I think this is one player that it's hard to argue needs (and needed) to go. If he can't stay healthy, he isn't much use.

Re: Hall to be replaced?
 

[QUOTE=onlydarksets;226745]I think this is one player that it's hard to argue needs (and needed) to go. If he can't stay healthy, he isn't much use.[/QUOTE]

Yup. That sums it up.

Re: Hall to be replaced?
 

They have mentioned Cortez.

I think I just threw up in my mouth!

Re: Hall to be replaced?
 

Todd Peterson sucks...we need to get edinger or novak

and the punter todd sauerbrun just got cut today from the broncos. He is a lot better than frost and his suspension is over

Re: Hall to be replaced?
 

[quote=steveo395;226780]Todd Peterson sucks...we need to get edinger or novak

and the punter todd sauerbrun just got cut today from the broncos. He is a lot better than frost and his suspension is over[/quote]

doubt it b/c of his character (suspension) , but he is so much better than frost

Re: Hall to be replaced?
 

[quote=dall-assblows;226787]doubt it b/c of his character (suspension) , but he is so much better than frost[/quote]
he got suspended for taking ephedra...thats not that bad

Re: Hall to be replaced?
 

[quote=steveo395;226780]and the punter todd sauerbrun just got cut today from the broncos. He is a lot better than frost and his suspension is over[/quote]

Frost has been fine so far, with one exception. No need to screw up our punting, too.